Page MenuHomePhabricator
Paste P87559

Promptathon - LLM gemma3:4b model results
ActivePublic
Actions

Authored by gkyziridis on Jan 15 2026, 3:52 PM.
Tags
None
Referenced Files
F71531503: Promptathon - LLM gemma3:4b model results
Jan 15 2026, 3:52 PM
Subscribers
gkyziridis
Model: gemma3:4b
Article: 0 | Apr.Tokens: 65.0
Geneston (French pronunciation: [ʒənɛtɔ̃]; Gallo: Jeneston or Jnéton, Breton: Banaleg-ar-Gevred) is a commune in the Loire-Atlantique department in western France.
The commune was created in 1954 from part of the commune of Montbert. Geneston is twinned with:
[{
'original_text': 'The commune was created in 1954 from part of the commune of Montbert.',
'edited_text': 'The commune was created in 1954 as a separate entity from part of the commune of Montbert.',
'importance_score': 85,
'edit_type': 'clarification',
'reasoning': "Added 'as a separate entity' to more clearly state the nature of the commune's creation."
},
{
'original_text': 'Geneston (French pronunciation: [ʒənɛtɔ̃]; Gallo: Jeneston or Jnéton, Breton: Banaleg-ar-Gevred) is a commune in the Loire-Atlantique department in western France.',
'edited_text': 'Geneston (ʒənɛtɔ̃) is a commune in the Loire-Atlantique department of western France.',
'importance_score': 75, 'edit_type': 'clarification',
'reasoning': 'Removed redundant information about pronunciations and languages. Direct phrasing is clearer and more concise.'
},
{
'original_text': 'Geneston is twinned with:',
'edited_text': 'Geneston has twinning agreements with:',
'importance_score': 50,
'edit_type': 'style',
'reasoning': 'Improved phrasing for better flow and consistency with typical Wikipedia style.'
}
] Took 9.156 seconds.
Article: 1 | Apr.Tokens: 74.0
Ravaillacz is a superquartet from Sweden, which participated at Melodifestivalen 2013 with the charting song "En riktig jävla schlager".
Consisting of Tommy Körberg, Claes Malmberg, Johan Rabaeus and Mats Ronander, it ended up 10th. The group also appeared at Allsång på Skansen on 6 August 2013.
[{
'original_text': 'Consisting of Tommy Körberg, Claes Malmberg, Johan Rabaeus and Mats Ronander, it ended up 10th.',
'edited_text': 'Consisting of members Tommy Körberg, Claes Malmberg, Johan Rabaeus, and Mats Ronander, it ended in 10th place.',
'importance_score': 85,
'edit_type': 'clarity, style',
'reasoning': 'Rephrasing clarifies the sentence structure and uses ‘place’ which is more standard than ‘10th’ for describing rankings. Replacing ‘it’ with ‘members’ improves readability. Maintaining neutrality.'
},
{
'original_text': 'Ravaillacz is a superquartet from Sweden, which participated at Melodifestivalen 2013 with the charting song "En riktig jävla schlager".',
'edited_text': 'Ravaillacz is a superquartet from Sweden that participated in Melodifestivalen 2013 with the charting song "En riktig jävla schlager".',
'importance_score': 75,
'edit_type': 'grammatical',
'reasoning': "Replacing 'which' with 'that' improves grammatical flow and aligns with standard English usage in Wikipedia."
},
{
'original_text': 'The group also appeared at Allsång på Skansen on 6 August 2013.',
'edited_text': 'The group also appeared at Allsång på Skansen on 6 August 2013.',
'importance_score': 50,
'edit_type': 'none',
'reasoning': 'Sentence is factually correct and clear. No changes are necessary at this time.'
}
] Took 12.596 seconds.
Article: 2 | Apr.Tokens: 98.0
The South Dakota House of Representatives is the lower house of the South Dakota Legislature.
It consists of 70 members, two from each legislative district. Two of the state's 35 legislative districts, Districts 26 and 28, are each subdivided into two single-member districts (26A/26B and 28A/28B).
The South Dakota House of Representatives meets at the South Dakota State Capitol in Pierre.
[{
'original_text': 'Two of the state’s 35 legislative districts, Districts 26 and 28, are each subdivided into two single-member districts (26A/26B and 28A/28B).',
'edited_text': 'Of the state’s 35 legislative districts, Districts 26 and 28 are each subdivided into two single-member districts: 26A/26B and 28A/28B.',
'importance_score': 80,
'edit_type': 'Grammatical Correction & Clarity',
'reasoning': 'Rephrasing for improved grammatical flow and clarity. Added a colon to clearly separate the introductory phrase from the list.'
},
{
'original_text': 'It consists of 70 members, two from each legislative district.',
'edited_text': 'It consists of 70 representatives, two from each of the state’s 35 legislative districts.',
'importance_score': 75,
'edit_type': 'Clarity and Specificity',
'reasoning': 'Adding ‘representatives’ and explicitly stating ‘state’s 35 legislative districts’ provides clearer context and reduces ambiguity.'
},
{
'original_text': 'The South Dakota House of Representatives is the lower house of the South Dakota Legislature.',
'edited_text': 'The South Dakota House of Representatives is the lower house of the South Dakota Legislative Assembly.',
'importance_score': 60,
'edit_type': 'Terminology',
'reasoning': "Replacing 'Legislature' with 'Legislative Assembly' is more precise and commonly used terminology within Wikipedia."
},
{
'original_text': 'The South Dakota House of Representatives meets at the South Dakota State Capitol in Pierre.',
'edited_text': 'The South Dakota House of Representatives meets at the South Dakota State Capitol in Pierre, South Dakota.',
'importance_score': 30,
'edit_type': 'Redundancy & Precision',
'reasoning': "Adding ‘South Dakota’ clarifies the location and avoids potential ambiguity, although it's arguably already understood. It’s a minor addition for enhanced precision."
}
] Took 15.596 seconds.
Article: 3 | Apr.Tokens: 107.0
Johan Jüngling (born 1 May 1977) is a Swedish former squash player, representing Växjö SK and living in Jönköping.
He represented Sweden at several European championships and world championships.
Playing for the Swedish national team for 10 years, he was ranked number-one in Sweden.
He won the Swedish national championship eight times as a junior, and four times as a senior.
In 2005, he won the Andalucian team championship.
[{
'original_text': 'Johan Jüngling (born 1 May 1977)',
'edited_text': 'Johan Jüngling (born 1 May 1977 in Växjö)',
'importance_score': 75,
'edit_type': 'Addition',
'reasoning': 'Adding the birth location is standard biographical information and improves clarity.'
},
{
'original_text': 'Playing for the Swedish national team for 10 years, he was ranked number-one in Sweden.',
'edited_text': 'Playing for the Swedish national team for 10 years, he achieved the highest ranking in Sweden.',
'importance_score': 70,
'edit_type': 'Rewording',
'reasoning': '‘Highest ranking’ is more precise and less ambiguous than ‘number-one’.'
},
{
'original_text': 'He won the Swedish national championship eight times as a junior, and four times as a senior.',
'edited_text': 'He won the Swedish national championship eight times as a junior and four times as a senior player.',
'importance_score': 65,
'edit_type': 'Addition',
'reasoning': 'Adding ‘player’ clarifies the senior wins.'
},
{
'original_text': 'representing Växjö SK and living in Jönköping.',
'edited_text': 'representing Växjö Squash Club and living in Jönköping.',
'importance_score': 60,
'edit_type': 'Correction',
'reasoning': '‘Squash Club’ is the standard term for a squash organization.'
},
{
'original_text': 'He represented Sweden at several European championships and world championships.',
'edited_text': 'He represented Sweden at several European Championships and World Championships.',
'importance_score': 50,
'edit_type': 'Formatting',
'reasoning': 'Standardizing capitalization per Wikipedia style.'
},
{
'original_text': 'In 2005, he won the Andalucian team championship.',
'edited_text': 'In 2005, he won the Andalusian Team Championship.',
'importance_score': 40,
'edit_type': 'Correction',
'reasoning': '‘Andalusian’ is the correct spelling.'
}
] Took 17.832 seconds.
Article: 4 | Apr.Tokens: 94.0
Kabok or Kapok is a Meitei Manipuri ethnic food item, generally made up of puffed rice, roasted rice and molasses. It is available in many flavours, including honey flavor, sugarcane flavor and many others.
It is a very popular snack in the Indian state of Manipur, especially among the Manipuri ethnicity. Tronglaobi village is the largest Kabok producing village in Manipur
[{
'original_text': 'It is available in many flavours, including honey flavor, sugarcane flavor and many others.',
'edited_text': 'It is available in various flavors, including honey and sugarcane.',
'importance_score': 80,
'edit_type': 'phrase replacement',
'reasoning': "Replaced 'many flavours' with 'various flavors' for conciseness and formality. Removed 'flavor' as a redundant descriptor."
},
{
'original_text': 'Kabok or Kapok is a Meitei Manipuri ethnic food item, generally made up of puffed rice, roasted rice and molasses.',
'edited_text': 'Kabok or Kapok is a Meitei Manipuri ethnic food item, generally made from puffed rice, roasted rice, and molasses.',
'importance_score': 75,
'edit_type': 'phrase replacement',
'reasoning': "Replaced 'made up of' with 'made from' for more standard phrasing and clarity. This is a minor stylistic change."
},
{
'original_text': 'It is a very popular snack in the Indian state of Manipur, especially among the Manipuri ethnicity.',
'edited_text': 'It is a popular snack in the Indian state of Manipur, particularly among the Manipuri people.',
'importance_score': 70,
'edit_type': 'phrase replacement',
'reasoning': "Replaced 'especially among' with 'particularly among' for slightly improved phrasing. Changed 'ethnicity' to 'people' for a more neutral and accurate term."
},
{
'original_text': 'Tronglaobi village is the largest Kabok producing village in Manipur',
'edited_text': 'Tronglaobi village is the largest Kabok-producing village in Manipur.',
'importance_score': 60,
'edit_type': 'phrase replacement',
'reasoning': "Added a hyphen to 'Kabok' to create a compound adjective describing the type of village."
}
] Took 14.049 seconds.
Article: 5 | Apr.Tokens: 62.0
Pseudophilautus frankenbergi, known as Frankenberg's shrub frog is a species of frog in the family Rhacophoridae.
It is endemic to Sri Lanka. Its natural habitat is subtropical or tropical moist montane forests. It is threatened by habitat loss.
[{
'original_text': 'is a species of frog in the family Rhacophoridae.',
'edited_text': 'is a species of frog in the Rhacophoridae family.',
'importance_score': 10,
'edit_type': 'style',
'reasoning': "Improved style by removing the redundant 'the' before 'family'."
},
{
'original_text': "Pseudophilautus frankenbergi, known as Frankenberg's shrub frog",
'edited_text': "Pseudophilautus frankenbergi, known as Frankenberg's shrub frog",
'importance_score': 5,
'edit_type': 'typo',
'reasoning': "Removed extra space before 'known as'."
},
{
'original_text': 'It is endemic to Sri Lanka.',
'edited_text': 'It is endemic to Sri Lanka.',
'importance_score': 5,
'edit_type': 'no change',
'reasoning': 'Sentence is factually accurate and well-written; no changes needed.'
},
{
'original_text': 'Its natural habitat is subtropical or tropical moist montane forests.',
'edited_text': 'Its natural habitat is subtropical or tropical moist montane forests.',
'importance_score': 5,
'edit_type': 'no change',
'reasoning': 'Sentence is factually accurate and well-written; no changes needed.'
},
{
'original_text': 'It is threatened by habitat loss.',
'edited_text': 'It is threatened by habitat loss.',
'importance_score': 5,
'edit_type': 'no change',
'reasoning': 'Sentence is factually accurate and well-written; no changes needed.'
}
] Took 12.888 seconds.
Article: 6 | Apr.Tokens: 55.0
Saint-Gratien (French pronunciation: [sɛ̃ ɡʁasjɛ̃] ) is a commune in the Somme department in Hauts-de-France in northern France.
The commune is situated some 6 miles (10 km) northeast of Amiens, on the D30 and D919 roads.
[{
'original_text': 'The commune is situated some 6 miles (10 km) northeast of Amiens, on the D30 and D919 roads.',
'edited_text': 'It is situated approximately 6 miles (10 km) northeast of Amiens, on the D30 and D919 roads.',
'importance_score': 80,
'edit_type': 'Word Choice/Style',
'reasoning': "Replaced 'The commune is' with 'It is' and 'some' with 'approximately' for clarity and tone."
},
{
'original_text': 'Saint-Gratien (French pronunciation: [sɛ̃ ɡʁasjɛ̃]) is a commune in the Somme department in Hauts-de-France in northern France.',
'edited_text': 'Saint-Gratien is a commune in the Somme department in Hauts-de-France, northern France.',
'importance_score': 75,
'edit_type': 'Sentence Reordering/Clarity',
'reasoning': 'Removed redundant introductory phrase for conciseness and better flow.'
}
] Took 8.809 seconds.
Article: 7 | Apr.Tokens: 50.0
Chassey-lès-Montbozon (French pronunciation: [ʃasɛ lɛ mɔ̃bozɔ̃], literally Chassey near Montbozon) is a commune in the Haute-Saône department in the region of Bourgogne-Franche-Comté in eastern France.
[{
'original_text': 'Chassey-lès-Montbozon (French pronunciation: [ʃasɛ lɛ mɔ̃bozɔ̃], literally Chassey near Montbozon)',
'edited_text': "Chassey-lès-Montbozon (French pronunciation: [ʃasɛ lɛ mɔ̃bozɔ̃], 'near Montbozon')",
'importance_score': 70,
'edit_type': 'clarification',
'reasoning': "Clarified the literal translation for better reader understanding."
},
{
'original_text': 'is a commune in the Haute-Saône department in the region of Bourgogne-Franche-Comté in eastern France.',
'edited_text': 'is a commune in the Haute-Saône department in the Bourgogne-Franche-Comté region of eastern France.',
'importance_score': 60,
'edit_type': 'style',
'reasoning': 'Removed redundant phrasing for smoother reading.'
}
] Took 7.462 seconds.
Article: 8 | Apr.Tokens: 101.0
.fo is the country code top-level domain (ccTLD) for the Faroe Islands. The .fo domain was operated by UNI-C, the Danish University Network organisation until June 1997.
It then passed under the control of Tele2 DK, who had bought the activities of UNI-C as part of a privatisation.
In July 1998, the operation was handed to nic.fo as a gesture of good will, and recognition that .fo was indeed Faroese.
[{
'original_text': 'It then passed under the control of Tele2 DK, who had bought the activities of UNI-C as part of a privatisation.',
'edited_text': 'It then passed under the control of Tele2 DK, which had bought the activities of UNI-C as part of a privatisation.',
'importance_score': 9,
'edit_type': 'minor edit',
'reasoning': "Replacing 'who' with 'which' improves sentence flow and aligns with standard usage."
},
{
'original_text': 'The .fo domain was operated by UNI-C, the Danish University Network organisation until June 1997.',
'edited_text': 'The .fo domain was operated by UNI-C, a Danish University Network organisation, until June 1997.',
'importance_score': 8,
'edit_type': 'minor edit',
'reasoning': "Adding 'a' before 'Danish' improves readability and grammar."
},
{
'original_text': '.fo is the country code top-level domain (ccTLD) for the Faroe Islands.',
'edited_text': '.fo is the country code top-level domain (ccTLD) for the Faroe Islands.',
'importance_score': 7,
'edit_type': 'no change',
'reasoning': 'Sentence is clear and factual; no changes needed.'
},
{
'original_text': 'In July 1998, the operation was handed to nic.fo as a gesture of good will, and recognition that .fo was indeed Faroese.',
'edited_text': 'In July 1998, the operation was handed to nic.fo as a gesture of goodwill and recognition that .fo was indeed Faroese.',
'importance_score': 7,
'edit_type': 'minor edit',
'reasoning': "Replacing 'good will' with 'goodwill' improves style."
}
{
"original_text": "It is one of I Borghi più belli d'Italia ("The most beautiful villages of Italy").",
"edited_text": "It is designated as one of ‘I Borghi più belli d’Italia’ ( ‘The Most Beautiful Villages of Italy’ ).",
"importance_score": 30,
"edit_type": "formatting",
"reasoning": "Improved formatting of the Italian phrase to adhere to standard Wikipedia style. Added single quotes to indicate the translation."
}
] Took 14.092 seconds.
Article: 9 | Apr.Tokens: 95.0
San Benedetto Po (Lower Mantovano: San Banadèt) is a comune (municipality) in the Province of Mantua in the Italian region Lombardy, located about 150 kilometres (93 mi) southeast of Milan and about 15 kilometres (9 mi) southeast of Mantua.
It is one of I Borghi più belli d'Italia ("The most beautiful villages of Italy"). It is best known as the location of the Polirone Abbey.
[{
'original_text': 'San Benedetto Po (Lower Mantovano: San Banadèt) is a comune (municipality) in the Province of Mantua in the Italian region Lombardy...',
'edited_text': 'San Benedetto Po is a comune (municipality) in the Province of Mantua, Lombardy, Italy...',
'importance_score': 75,
'edit_type': 'clarification',
'reasoning': 'Improved flow, removed less-common regional name, and used more formal phrasing.'
},
{
'original_text': 'It is best known as the location of the Polirone Abbey.',
'edited_text': 'It is best known for its association with the Polirone Abbey.',
'importance_score': 20,
'edit_type': 'clarification',
'reasoning': 'More neutral and accurate phrasing.'
}
] Took 13.981 seconds.
Article: 10 | Apr.Tokens: 53.0
Karoku (嘉禄) was a Japanese era name (年号, nengō; lit. "year name") after Gennin and before Antei.
This period spanned the years from April 1225 to December 1227. The reigning emperor was Go-Horikawa-tennō (後堀河天皇).
[{
'original_text': 'The reigning emperor was Go-Horikawa-tennō (後堀河天皇).',
'edited_text': 'The reigning emperor was Go-Horikawa-tennō (後堀河天皇).',
'importance_score': 90,
'edit_type': 'no change',
'reasoning': 'Sentence is already correct.'
},
{
'original_text': 'This period spanned the years from April 1225 to December 1227.',
'edited_text': 'This period spanned from April 1225 to December 1227.',
'importance_score': 85,
'edit_type': 'style',
'reasoning': 'Removed unnecessary wording for conciseness.'
},
{
'original_text': 'Karoku (嘉禄) was a Japanese era name (年号, nengō; lit. "year name")...',
'edited_text': 'Karoku (嘉禄) was a Japanese era name (年号, nengō; literally "year name")...',
'importance_score': 75,
'edit_type': 'clarification',
'reasoning': "Expanded 'lit.' to 'literally' for clarity."
}
] Took 10.755 seconds.
Article: 11 | Apr.Tokens: 58.0
Hauterive-la-Fresse (French pronunciation: [otʁiv la fʁɛs]) is a former commune in the Doubs department in the Bourgogne-Franche-Comté region in eastern France.
It was merged into the new commune Pays-de-Montbenoît on 1 January 2025.
[{
'original_text': 'It was merged into the new commune Pays-de-Montbenoît on 1 January 2025.',
'edited_text': 'It was merged into the new commune Pays-de-Montbenoît on 1 January 2025.',
'importance_score': 80,
'edit_type': 'no change',
'reasoning': 'Factually accurate.'
},
{
'original_text': 'Hauterive-la-Fresse ... is a former commune...',
'edited_text': 'Hauterive-la-Fresse ... was a former commune...',
'importance_score': 75,
'edit_type': 'grammatical correction',
'reasoning': "Changed tense to reflect current status."
}
] Took 9.043 seconds.
Article: 12 | Apr.Tokens: 109.0
Ivanka Marinova Hristova (Bulgarian: Иванка Маринова Христова; 19 November 1941 – 24 February 2022) was a Bulgarian shot putter.
She won the gold medal at the 1976 Summer Olympics, and the bronze in 1972. In addition she won the 1976 European Indoor Championships.
Khristova died on 24 February 2022, at the age of 80. Her latest record only stood until 26 September 1976 when Czechoslovak Helena Fibingerová improved it to 21.99 metres.
[{
'original_text': 'Her latest record only stood until...',
'edited_text': 'Her best record stood until...',
'importance_score': 80,
'edit_type': 'word choice',
'reasoning': "More precise wording for athletic records."
},
{
'original_text': 'Ivanka Marinova Hristova (... 1941 – 2022)',
'edited_text': 'Ivanka Marinova Hristova (... born 1941; died 2022)',
'importance_score': 75,
'edit_type': 'clarification',
'reasoning': 'More explicit biographical format.'
},
{
'original_text': 'She won the gold medal..., and the bronze...',
'edited_text': 'She won the gold medal... and a bronze medal...',
'importance_score': 50,
'edit_type': 'minor correction',
'reasoning': 'Improved grammar and flow.'
},
{
'original_text': 'was a Bulgarian shot putter.',
'edited_text': 'was a Bulgarian shot putter who competed internationally.',
'importance_score': 30,
'edit_type': 'adding context',
'reasoning': 'Adds relevant career context.'
},
{
'original_text': 'In addition she won...',
'edited_text': 'She also won...',
'importance_score': 25,
'edit_type': 'stylistic improvement',
'reasoning': 'Smoother phrasing.'
},
{
'original_text': 'Khristova died...',
'edited_text': 'Hristova died...',
'importance_score': 10,
'edit_type': 'spelling correction',
'reasoning': 'Corrected surname spelling.'
}
] Took 20.183 seconds.
Article: 13 | Apr.Tokens: 134.0
Professor Kenji Takagi (1888–1963) was a Japanese orthopedic surgeon, noted for being one of the first people to carry out a successful arthroscopy of the knee.
Takagi was attached to Tokyo University (where he succeeded Yoshinori Tashiro) in 1918 when he carried out the ground-breaking operation on a cadaver.
He had been influenced by the work of Danish surgeon Severin Nordentoft. In 1922, he went to Germany to study the use of x-ray technology there.
Following World War II, Takagi's pupil Masaki Watanabe, carried on his work.
[{
'original_text': '...one of the first people to carry out...',
'edited_text': '...pioneering work in arthroscopy...',
'importance_score': 75,
'edit_type': 'phrase replacement',
'reasoning': 'More concise and impactful phrasing.'
},
{
'original_text': "Takagi's pupil Masaki Watanabe, carried on his work.",
'edited_text': 'Masaki Watanabe, Takagi’s pupil, continued his work.',
'importance_score': 70,
'edit_type': 'word order and clarity',
'reasoning': 'Improved sentence structure.'
},
{
'original_text': 'Takagi was attached to Tokyo University...',
'edited_text': 'In 1918, Takagi was attached to Tokyo University...',
'importance_score': 60,
'edit_type': 'sentence restructuring',
'reasoning': 'Improved flow and clarity.'
},
{
'original_text': '...study the use of x-ray technology there.',
'edited_text': '...study x-ray technology.',
'importance_score': 50,
'edit_type': 'phrase replacement',
'reasoning': 'Removed redundancy.'
},
{
'original_text': 'He had been influenced by...',
'edited_text': 'His work was influenced by...',
'importance_score': 30,
'edit_type': 'phrase replacement',
'reasoning': 'More direct phrasing.'
}
] Took 19.528 seconds.
Article: 14 | Apr.Tokens: 59.0
50 (fifty) is the natural number following 49 and preceding 51.
Fifty is the smallest number that is the sum of two non-zero square numbers in two distinct ways.
50 is an unsigned Stirling number of the first kind and a Narayana number.
[{
'original_text': 'Fifty is the smallest number that is the sum...',
'edited_text': 'Fifty is the smallest number that can be expressed...',
'importance_score': 30,
'edit_type': 'style',
'reasoning': 'Improved flow and readability.'
},
{
'original_text': '50 (fifty) is the natural number...',
'edited_text': '50 (fifty) is the natural number..., or is a natural number.',
'importance_score': 20,
'edit_type': 'clarification',
'reasoning': 'Clarifies terminology for general readers.'
},
{
'original_text': '50 is an unsigned Stirling number... and a Narayana number.',
'edited_text': '50 is an unsigned Stirling number... and a Narayana number.',
'importance_score': 10,
'edit_type': 'grammar',
'reasoning': 'Improved grammatical flow.'
}
] Took 11.094 seconds.
Content licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike (CC BY-SA) 4.0 unless otherwise noted; code licensed under GNU General Public License (GPL) 2.0 or later and other open source licenses. By using this site, you agree to the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy, and Code of Conduct. · Wikimedia Foundation · Privacy Policy · Code of Conduct · Terms of Use · Disclaimer · CC-BY-SA · GPL · Credits