When you click thank in history for a wiki page edit, there's a confirmation question: "Send public thanks for this edit? Yes No"
Should we have that on Flow posts?
When you click thank in history for a wiki page edit, there's a confirmation question: "Send public thanks for this edit? Yes No"
Should we have that on Flow posts?
I think people generally prefer undo support (it would make sense to do it for all of desktop/mobile, Flow/non-Flow, we have it for none currently).
See T71636: Thanks: Implement an undo feature and linked tasks.
+1. Just noticed this on mediawiki.org. There's a Thank button for every post at https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Topic:Sgfi0l5w96dhfmqb and clicking it immediately performs the action.
There is no confirmation step, no undo option, and also it doesn't seem very clear what happened or where it goes. The only thing that changes is it changing to "Thanked" and no longer being clickable. Although the clickable and unclickable variant are styled and positioned the same, yet behave different (UX inconsistency).
Also, on refresh it is gone. So I can apparently click it again the next time. This is inconsistent with e.g. action=history of a regular wiki page where the change to "Thanked" is permanent and survives a refresh.
In Vector:
Granted, the differences between the two not-hovered gray is very subtle. But the more important differences are:
However, there may be ways to make it more obvious. What do you have in mind?
Also, on refresh it is gone. So I can apparently click it again the next time.
It won't actually send thanks a second time. Nevertheless, this is a bug: T101342: Don't make it seem user can re-thank for a Flow post when they already did; render server-side