And T33552: [DO NOT USE] PDF related (Collection extension) bugs (tracking) [superseded by #Collection] can also be closed in favor of Collection
Description
Description
Related Objects
Related Objects
- Mentioned In
- T192655: Replace all "tracking" tasks with tags/projects (if unbounded), relabel them to outcome tasks (if bounded), or kill them entirely (if pointless)
T2209: [DO NOT USE] HTML validity (tracking)
T33552: [DO NOT USE] PDF related (Collection extension) bugs (tracking) [superseded by #Collection]
T43037: [DO NOT USE] PDF related bugs and enhancements (tracking) - Mentioned Here
- T43037: [DO NOT USE] PDF related bugs and enhancements (tracking)
T33552: [DO NOT USE] PDF related (Collection extension) bugs (tracking) [superseded by #Collection]
Event Timeline
Comment Actions
There should be two different projects for PDF tracking.
One for PDF uploaded files, one for PDF export.
Comment Actions
There are numerous PDF related projects related to creation/export of PDFs: OCG-PDFRenderer, OCG-PDF-renderer, Collection, MediaWiki-extensions-PdfBook, Electron-PDFs. There is MediaWiki-extensions-PdfHandler (for displaying), MediaWiki-File-management (covering the thumbnail creation part in MediaWiki), and Wikimedia-Media-storage superseded by SRE-swift-storage for file storage issues on Wikimedia wikis. What does "for PDF uploaded files" mean and which additional value does it provide compared to the existing projects, also when it comes to superseding T33552 and T43037?
Comment Actions
Nowadays there are already numerous PDF related projects related to PDFs: Deprecated OCG-PDFRenderer, deprecated OCG-PDF-renderer, Collection, MediaWiki-extensions-PdfBook, the browser-based Electron-PDFs service, the 'new' renderer Proton. There is MediaWiki-extensions-PdfHandler (for displaying), MediaWiki-File-management (covering the thumbnail creation part in MediaWiki), and Wikimedia-Media-storage superseded by SRE-swift-storage for file storage issues on Wikimedia wikis.
I do not see any sense to keep this Bugzilla-days tracking task open. Hence I propose to decline T43037 and T102513. People can watch/query the aforementioned projects, and/or people can query for 'PDF'. Plus the current list of subtasks in T43037 is very incomplete so T43037 does not serve its purpose anymore anyway.