Page MenuHomePhabricator

Use text cursor when hovering links instead of pointer ("hand") one
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

We observed users to be reluctant to click on links when editing them because they expected the links to open. It seems the hand cursor may be conveying that idea. Thus, we may want to:

  • Use the text editing cursor for links on the source and target areas.
  • Use the hand cursor when the user hovers a link with shift pressed, since links are opened when using such modificator.
  • Use the hand link when there is text selected in the translation and the user hovers a link in the source text. We want to communicate that an action with side-effects is about to happen since the target text will be turned into a link once the user clicks on the source link.

Event Timeline

Pginer-WMF raised the priority of this task from Medium to Needs Triage.Jul 21 2015, 9:24 PM

Double-checking: Can we treat the opening description as sufficient user testing to start the implementation?

Is it good first task? :)

Amire80 triaged this task as Medium priority.Jul 28 2015, 6:46 PM
Amire80 moved this task from Needs Triage to CX6 on the ContentTranslation board.
Amire80 set Security to None.

Can we treat the opening description as sufficient user testing to start the implementation?

I think the initial observations confirm the problem exists. The only question is whether the proposed solution would work.
I think it is a reasonable assumption and I don't see much risk in trying it. If there is any concern we can do it closer to when we plan our next round of usability testing to check if any unexpected issues appear, but I don't think that focusing a specific testing session or prototyping this change represents the UX area where to make the biggest research effort in terms of risk/benefit.

Is it Easy? :)

I think it is.

I am note sure whether a edit cursor will be inviting to click and use link tool. If Pau is doing a usability testing in coming days, I think it is better to test it.

There is another use case of selecting text and clicking a link in source column to adapt. If we show a non-pointer cursor, won't it be an issue?

There is another use case of selecting text and clicking a link in source column to adapt. If we show a non-pointer cursor, won't it be an issue?

In that case it also makes sense to keep the hand cursor. I'll add the details at the description on top.

Using a user-specific CSS we can test the simple version of this easily (using text cursor for links) but for a more complete behaviour we may need to enable it as an experimental feature. I'm ok in testing the former in an upcoming round of tests. This does not seem to be in the "critical bugs" category, so there is no need to rush on it in any case.

Arrbee claimed this task.