Page MenuHomePhabricator

Wikipedia Ops & Maintenance shortcuts are all "off the radar" from the search box
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

The following Wikipedia project pages are out of service for search suggestions:

  • CAT: for shortcuts to the Category namespace: 80 pp.
  • H: for shortcuts to the Help namespace: 462 pp.
  • MOS: for shortcuts to the Manual of Style: 640 pp.
  • P: for shortcuts to the Portal namespace: 747 pp.
  • T: for shortcuts to the Template namespace: 74 pp.

That's two thousand helpful search-box hints not being suggested.

Auto-suggestions that drop down from the search box have two telling flaws:

  1. All shortcuts to project pages are out of service.
  2. Suffixing "WP:" or "Wikipedia" puts the shortcut names in service.

To see this pick a Wikipedia pseudo-namespace, say the Wikipedia Manual of Style:

  1. Go to Special:All pages with prefix/MOS: on Wikipedia. You will see many shortcuts to the Manual of Style.
  2. Type in a partial prefix, say MOS:DA. That should obviously drop-down several suggested pagenames, but is silent.
  3. Now type WP:MOS:DA into the search box. You get pagenames suggested. Select one. You go to a non-existent page.

Shortcuts are the pagenames of the most-needed, most oft-used project documentation for editors and administrators. Suggestions are synergistic with shortcuts, amplifying the intention of shortcuts, which is to facilitate productivity tasks.

Event Timeline

Cpiral raised the priority of this task from to Needs Triage.
Cpiral updated the task description. (Show Details)
Cpiral subscribed.
Cpiral set Security to None.
Cpiral renamed this task from Search autosuggestions or typeahead are not reliable to ElasticSearch schema is wrong: shortcut pagenames are in project namespace..Oct 2 2015, 5:29 PM
Cpiral updated the task description. (Show Details)

Shortcuts are the titles of mainspace, redirect pages. They're dressed up to look like namespaces, i.e. pseudo-namespaces, e.g. MOS: for popular Manual of Style references and H: for popular Help references, like H:S for Help:Searching, but shortcuts are not in any namespace. Although shortcuts target project space, they are pagenames in article space.

Currently the ElasticSearch schema is structured as if shortcut pagenames were found in project namespace, when in reality project namespace is just the target. As a consequence users currently get no hints for accessing maintenance docs.

For more background info:

This task seems easy, and fixes a serious maintenance problem.

Cpiral renamed this task from ElasticSearch schema is wrong: shortcut pagenames are in project namespace. to Schema is wrong: shortcut pagenames are in project namespace..Oct 7 2015, 6:05 AM
Cpiral renamed this task from Schema is wrong: shortcut pagenames are in project namespace. to Project pagenames are in the wrong namespace..Oct 8 2015, 5:31 AM
Cpiral updated the task description. (Show Details)

Wikipedia Operations & Maintenance pages are now "off the radar".

As the removal of a former, working tool, it affects experienced users.

As a factual avenue of curiosity, it affects new users.

This bug, if left untreated, will eventually hamper, at some point, all users efforts to improve the encyclopedia.

Cpiral renamed this task from Project pagenames are in the wrong namespace. to All shortcut suggestions to the main WP maintenance pages are "offline", lying silent..Oct 13 2015, 8:14 PM
Cpiral updated the task description. (Show Details)
Cpiral renamed this task from All shortcut suggestions to the main WP maintenance pages are "offline", lying silent. to Wikipedia Ops & Maintenance shortcuts are all "off the radar" from the search box.Nov 3 2015, 12:43 AM

The lead sentence of WP:Shortcut may have confused a developer. It read "A shortcut is a specialized type of redirect page that provides an abbreviated wikilink to a project page or one of its sections, usually from the Wikipedia namespace." There is a debate about whether or not to delete all shortcuts in article space, but even the staunchest supporter admits the longstanding MOS: prefix. If this bug persists for political reasons, it is tyranny, for I believe the consensus is to leave the "articles" that start with the four characters MOS: and are shortcuts to subpages and sections in WP:Manual of Style, are to be left intact.

EBernhardson claimed this task.
EBernhardson subscribed.

If I understand this task correctly, this was fixed some time in the last year with a reworking of how CirrusSearch treats cross-namespace redirects. I currently get completions for MOS:, such as MOS:DUPECITE and more. Please reopen if this is not the case.