Page MenuHomePhabricator

Add a possibility to save a page as pdf
Open, LowPublic

Event Timeline

Florian raised the priority of this task from to Lowest.
Florian updated the task description. (Show Details)
Florian added a project: Wikipedia-Android-App.
Florian subscribed.
Mholloway raised the priority of this task from Lowest to Low.Apr 20 2017, 2:14 PM
Mholloway updated the task description. (Show Details)
Mholloway subscribed.

This seems useful and not too much trouble to implement.

I'm curious what the use case of saving as PDF would be.

I'm curious what the use case of saving as PDF would be.

@atgo Am I mistaken in thinking that consuming and sharing articles as PDFs came up as a frequent use case in your new readers research?

To expand on my comment a bit:
It seems like these OTRS users want to save PDF versions of articles so that they have access to them offline (one of the OTRS comments states this explicitly), which likely comes from a misunderstanding of how our reading list feature works. Therefore, wouldn't it suffice for us to better communicate to our users that saving an article to a reading list equates to saving it for offline access? Is there something else that the user could do with a PDF copy of an article that they can't do by saving it to a reading list in the app?

Is there something else that the user could do with a PDF copy of an article that they can't do by saving it to a reading list in the app?

Print it.

Hello! The research supports that people are interested in saving and sharing offline, but doesn't specify the format. Through the concept research for the reading web team (round 1, round 2), we did find that PDFs were probably the best solution there, but I don't see that as prescriptive for the Android app.

I would invest in better messaging/understanding of the offline functionality within the app before going to PDFs. Do you guys do any tracking of volume of OTRS requests for things like this? It might be interesting to see if the volume drops with improvements to offline support.

Is there something else that the user could do with a PDF copy of an article that they can't do by saving it to a reading list in the app?

  • Share the offline PDF version of the article to another person whose device doesn't have internet connectivity.
  • Transfer the PDF file to a computer that doesn't have internet connectivity and allowing users to read in a large screen. This is a scenario that could possibly occur in my surroundings.