- Mentioned Here
- T128275: Preferences stuck/broken and can't be changed at nowiki
T128573: VisualEditor single tab popup should keep appearing until you use it
T128780: VisualEditor should show two tabs to all readers and users until they choose one on first edit
T128781: For users that ignore instructions, provide a second "this is how to switch editors" pop-up inside VisualEditor
T127942: Consider alternative wording/improve positioning for "You have switched to source editing" pop-up
T128060: VisualEditor makes it easy to create partially linked words, when the user expects a fully linked one
Some feedback collected from the village pump (mainly reactive, so biased towards problems) and on the admin list (actively solicited but biased towards users with high proficiency in wikitext):
- the change was surprising and only announcing it on the technical village pump was not enough notification, there should have been a watchlist notice or logged-in sitenotice. (That one is on me. Sorry.)
- people were confused by the tabs suddenly disappearing. As far as I can see the tabs disappear immediately but you only get the explanation when you try to edit. This was the largest problem IMO. Filed as T128780. Also made worse by...
- several people reported reflexively closing the popup and then having to spend a significant amount of time finding out what's going on and how to switch. Filed two suggestions: T128573, T128781
- T128275 complicated things - it lasted for about a day and caused most user pref changes to break (ie. the option dialogs did not work the way they were supposed to). Some people reported VE completely broken in that period.
- at least one very active editor is using anonymous editing, sometime from incognito mode, a lot, and is getting the popup all the time. Not much can be done about that, I suppose.
2 users gave feedback specific to single tabs in email, about a dozen on the village pumps. (As a baseline, huwiki has about 100 very active, 500 active editors.) By topic: 6 reported being unable to edit (most of that is T128275; some might simply not have realized that text is editable in the VE interface, looks too much like the article), 6 being confused by the change and having a hard time finding the preferences, 2 had no problems figuring out the change, one user couldn't figure out how to go back to VE after selecting wikitext default. On the whole I would say it wasn't terrible but didn't go smoothly either.