As pointed out by @matmarex the cross-out lines of icons are pointing into different directions
Description
Details
Subject | Repo | Branch | Lines +/- | |
---|---|---|---|---|
icons: Unify cross-out lines direction to top-left/bottom-right | oojs/ui | master | +12 -12 |
Status | Subtype | Assigned | Task | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Resolved | Volker_E | T132991 Various issues with OOUI's MediaWiki theme icons | |||
Resolved | Volker_E | T133076 Cross-out lines in OOUI's MediaWiki theme icons are pointing to different directions |
Event Timeline
I'd recommend going for bottom-left to top-right in LTR languages and bottom-right to top-left in RLT languages.
Any objections @Mooeypoo or @Pginer-WMF ?
That's actually a really interesting problem. I am actually not entirely sure that cross-out lines are rtl/ltr related, similarly to check-marks.
For example, I am left-handed, and my check-mark is flipped from a person who'd write it right-handed. That's not because of RTL, but because I am left-handed, and the motion of my hand is that way.
I am not sure we need to flip those, but since I am not sure if there is a convention in this case, I would defer to @Amire80's judgment (and ping him on this at the same time)
It's more an esthetic issue, if at all - how do they look next to other icons. Consistency may be important here. But they are understandable in any direction.
Thanks for asking!
There's another finding: Android (Material Design) uses in their LTR version top-left to bottom-right cross-out lines to indicate off state. With reading direction left-to-right several icons are also graph like featuring a bottom-left to top-right iconography. One important example is https://design.google.com/icons/#ic_signal_cellular_off
Therefore it seems advantegous to have the cross-out lines top-left to bottom-right.
Change 297186 had a related patch set uploaded (by VolkerE):
Unify cross-out lines direction in icons
Change 297186 merged by jenkins-bot:
icons: Unify cross-out lines direction to top-left/bottom-right