Page MenuHomePhabricator

Evaluate showing open section based on search engine referrer on mobile web
Open, MediumPublic

Description

When reading through User Research by @dchen on gathering user feedback and insights if open (uncollapsed) or closed (collapsed) sections are preferred, there were comments like “I don’t want to see everything, i want to see what i’m looking for”.
That made me think if it is possible to show users who are coming with a referrer the related section initially opened. It's seems probable that a majority of search results are not 1:1 translatable to sections. Still, for the clear cases that options seems experience-wise useful to consider.

There are –without question– several technical hurdles, still I'd like to see if there has been evaluations of technical hurdles connected with the issue.

Event Timeline

ovasileva triaged this task as Medium priority.Oct 5 2016, 4:16 PM
ovasileva added a project: Design.

This is a very cool idea. We need to manage expectations though, because (from what I've seen anecdotally recently when checking Google.* referers in the webrequest table, can do a more systematic check later) only a relatively small percentage of search engine referrals contain the query string. That might still mean tens of millions of pageviews per day, so I'm not saying it won't be worthwhile.

See also T144714

This feels like something better solved by search engines. Google for example already has a 'jump to"

Screen Shot 2017-06-27 at 3.48.14 PM.png (121×719 px, 33 KB)

While a good idea I personally think we should decline this.

That made me think if it is possible to show users who are coming with a referrer

What is referrer in this case?

If it is the section name ignore if not
are you saying referrer as in the section name appending with #?
in that case MF opens up that section. without any reference of what user is looking for it's difficult to know the context and open relevant section.

@Volker_E could you clarify the intention here? When I click on a link to a section within the article I land on the page scrolled to the open section, e.g.

image.png (1×1 px, 506 KB)

@alexhollender What you're seeing in the exemplified screen is some additional product feature by Google, what the task description is about is some additional product idea for us.

Consider the two search URLs:

We would take such referrer to point to an expanded section (same name or fuzzy resulted name) when accessing the mobile article.

Also note, that I didn't see those quick links in my test Google results, so it's not a widely provided feature for the time being.