Page MenuHomePhabricator

Explore designs for FileAnnotations
Open, MediumPublic

Description

This task and its sub-tasks captures different aspects of the FileAnnotations extension. Some of the documentation related to the design process can be found on mediawiki, but we'll slowly be moving all of that to Phabricator.

Initial sketches can be seen on -

  • Aspects to explore

    1. Typical user flow
      1. T151335: Discovery of annotations
      2. T151330: Encouraging users to annotate
      3. T151846: Adding FileAnnotations (on images)
      4. T151440: Review your annotation changes
      5. T151862: Show users that they're adding value when creating FileAnnotations
    2. Viewing
      1. T151847: Keeping context while viewing annotations
      2. Language switching
        1. See http://w3c.github.io/web-annotation/model/wd2/#choice-between-bodies
        2. For wikidata we can automatically switch the language to the current content or UI language
          1. If that language isn't available one we can traverse the language tree and find the closest one
        3. Have an option to open up ULS
        4. Allow transcriptions in multiple languages
    3. Editing
      1. T151857: Adding multiple FileAnnotations to the same area
      2. T151860: Adding FileAnnotations to small parts of the image

    Prototypes for T153296: Moderated usability testing for FileAnnotations prototypes

    1. View on Wikipedia, single tab annotation search
    2. View from Category:Needs annotation, multiple tab annotation search

    Related Objects

    StatusSubtypeAssignedTask
    DeclinedMarkTraceur
    OpenNone
    DeclinedNone
    DeclinedNone
    OpenNone
    DeclinedNone
    DeclinedNone
    DeclinedNone
    OpenNone
    DeclinedNone
    Declineddchen
    DeclinedNone
    DeclinedNone
    DeclinedNone
    DeclinedNone
    DeclinedNone
    DeclinedNone
    DeclinedNone
    DeclinedNone
    DeclinedNone
    DeclinedNone
    DeclinedNone
    DeclinedNone
    DeclinedNone

    Event Timeline

    Restricted Application added a subscriber: Aklapper. · View Herald Transcript
    Prtksxna updated the task description. (Show Details)
    MarkTraceur moved this task from Untriaged to Doing on the Multimedia board.
    This comment was removed by Prtksxna.

    http://w3c.github.io/web-annotation/model/wd2/#scope-of-a-resource - interesting concept - annotations that are specific to the usage of the image on certain articles. Maybe annotations that have such a scope defined could be visible on that page regardless of 'hover' etc.

    http://w3c.github.io/web-annotation/vocab/wd/#specificresource for Wikidata.

    Example Use Case: Qitara wants to tag a photo with an identifier for a city, rather than just type the city's name which could be ambiguous. Her client uses a well-known IRI for the city having done a search for it, and creates a Specific Resource to manage that purpose assignment.

    dr0ptp4kt changed the status of subtask T151860: Adding FileAnnotations to small parts of the image from Open to Stalled.
    dr0ptp4kt changed the status of subtask T151846: Adding FileAnnotations (on images) from Open to Stalled.
    dr0ptp4kt changed the status of subtask T151847: Keeping context while viewing annotations from Open to Stalled.
    dr0ptp4kt changed the status of subtask T151857: Adding multiple FileAnnotations to the same area from Open to Stalled.
    Ramsey-WMF changed the status of subtask T151335: Discovery of annotations from Open to Stalled.