Page MenuHomePhabricator

Make LocalisationUpdate run daily again on Wikimedia wikis
Closed, ResolvedPublic


SimmeD asked today how frequently translations are updated on Wikimedia wikis. Someone said that LocalisationUpdate is currently disabled, but I don't see a bug report, so I'm creating this one.

Our translators got used to a good service and they expect translations to flow on a daily basis. Otherwise all sorts of bad things happen, on which don't get me started. (Just a couple recent examples: one wiki had the logo and sidebar link a non-existing page instead of the main page for several days; some admins start customising messages locally, which add to long-term maintenance costs.)

I see there are some open reports such as T133913: Completely port l10nupdate to scap, but perfect is the enemy of good; restoring normal functionality doesn't need to be blocked on plans for possible future improvements.

Event Timeline

The latest mention I see in is on 2016-12-22:

22:11 thcipriani: disable l10nupdate cron for deployment freeze

This is quite counterintuitive: LocalisationUpdate is all the more needed when there are no code updates. Are there other issues?

I see there was some talk on the matter at but no announcement.

Right, it was disabled for the end of year code freeze. The change:

With the revert ready to go on Jan 3rd:

demon lowered the priority of this task from High to Medium.Dec 29 2016, 10:47 PM
demon added a subscriber: demon.

Not a high priority, this was planned.

Not a high priority, this was planned.

As far as I can see: it was suggested by one person, not properly announced or even discussed whether it actually makes sense (how often has it actually broken anything against the issues Nemo_bis wrote above?).

greg claimed this task.

This was re-enabled yesterday as planned.