Page MenuHomePhabricator

Cannot edit a translation in ContentTranslation: "Failed to load saved translation"
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

[French]

Bonjour,

La traduction de l'article « Safe-space » de <en> à <fr> est actuellement bloqué. Ce message s'affiche : « Il y a une traduction en cours par Superjuju10. Veuillez vous assurer que vous êtes coordonné avec l’utilisateur qui a effectué la traduction actuelle. » Or, j'ai fini par abandonner la traduction (que je n'avais pas commencé).

Impossible de faire quoi que ce soit, d'autant que s'affiche désormais un message « Échec au chargement de la traduction enregistrée ! ».

Merci de corriger ce conflit d'édition.

Cordialement,

[English]

Hello,

The translation of "Safe-space" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Safe-space from <en> to <fr> is currently blocked. This message appears (in French) " Il y a une traduction en cours par Superjuju10. Veuillez vous assurer que vous êtes coordonné avec l’utilisateur qui a effectué la traduction actuelle." However, I give up this translation in ContentTranslation (which I havn't start).

Unable to do anything, especially as now I get a message "Failed to load saved translation! ".

Please fix this edit conflict bug

Regards,

Event Timeline

In T152208: Articles deleted on CX are still considered as "in progress" the translation in progress cannot be dismissed (it's not clear if the article-translation-in-progress is removed after refreshing the page).

The bug reported is easily reproducible (wmf.12 testwiki):

  1. User X starts the translation and then discards it
  2. User Y attempts to start the translation for the same article (to the same language, of course), gets a greyed out screen with the warning: "This is ongoing translation by user X. ..."

Screen Shot 2017-02-15 at 3.12.50 PM.png (902×503 px, 98 KB)

  1. User X has nothing in 'In progress'. When attempting to start the translation of the article (the same article for which the previous translation was discarded) and gets "Failed to load the saved translation!"

Screen Shot 2017-02-15 at 12.50.38 PM.png (879×510 px, 152 KB)

Re-checked in .wmf15 - the issue is still present.

There is one more implication for the user Y form the previous comment: the article, in fact, is added to the user's list of translations 'In progress'. And the user Y cannot dismiss it. I attached the screen recording: the translation of an article is started by another user, and the article cannot be discarded by any of the users. And no user feedback is provided.

Aklapper renamed this task from Edit conflict bug in ContentTranslation to Cannot edit a translation in ContentTranslation: "Failed to load saved translation".Apr 6 2017, 2:10 PM
Nikerabbit claimed this task.
Nikerabbit triaged this task as High priority.
Nikerabbit moved this task from Bugs to Drafts and publishing on the ContentTranslation board.
Nikerabbit subscribed.

We changed it so that drafts are exclusive only for a day or so. This should greatly reduce the impact of this issue.