Page MenuHomePhabricator

Edit Counter Tool: Top edited pages
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

Edit Counter tool.

Feature request.

I noticed that on the beta XTools version of the Edit Counter the overview of the "Top edited pages" is missing. I find this overview, present in the current Edit Counter, really useful to see which particular articles I have worked the most on (or at least edited the most). Hopefully this can be carried over to the new tool both in the abbreviated and longer (-More-) version. If the entire section (Article, User, Talk, etc) can not be implemented then at least show the article list.

W7 / Chrome 60.0.3112.90

XTools version: 3.0.5-fc6bd36

Event Timeline

MusikAnimal subscribed.

We can look into this but note this information is still available at https://xtools.wmflabs.org/topedits

Was not aware of the separate tool for topedits. Still, the user case can be made that it is easier to have this in one tool instead of having to operate multiple tools. Furthermore the topedits tool shows only one namespace at a time whereas the current edit counter shows all namespaces. Showing "Top edited pages" also falls within the scope of an 'edit counter' so users may expect it here. The same can not really be said of the current section "Latest global edits" which is just a list view and does not count anything.

Was not aware of the separate tool for topedits. Still, the user case can be made that it is easier to have this in one tool instead of having to operate multiple tools. Furthermore the topedits tool shows only one namespace at a time whereas the current edit counter shows all namespaces. Showing "Top edited pages" also falls within the scope of an 'edit counter' so users may expect it here. The same can not really be said of the current section "Latest global edits" which is just a list view and does not count anything.

You can choose "All" from the namespace selector at https://xtools.wmflabs.org/topedits, this combines edits from every namespace rather than grouping them. Anyway, you're absolutely correct that this should live in the Edit Counter, just as it did before. The main issue is that things are already really slow as it is, but we plan to improve that with T163284. Once that's resolved we'll revisit adding more features.

MusikAnimal moved this task from Pending deployment to Complete on the XTools board.

It doesn't break down the top edited pages by namespace, but the overall top edited pages are now shown in the edit counter.