Page MenuHomePhabricator

Idea: When an article is changing during a short period in other languages, but not in others, notify the other languages through Notifications or talk page
Open, Needs TriagePublic

Description

This is an idea for creating a new feature to engage editors and facilitate collaboration between different languages.

It sometimes happens that an article exists in several languages, and something happens to the real life subject of the article,: For example, when a writer publishes a new book or when a city is chosen to host the Olympics. If people in several languages notice it, it is updated in several languages.

Sometimes people notice these changes and update the article, but it's possible that not all the people in all the languages notice it.

We could do some heuristics to notice that the article underwent changes in many languages and automatically notify people that the article in their language should be notified.

Who and now should be notified? Some ideas:

  • The authors of the article that weren't modified (through Notifications)
  • The people who made a change in one language, and also made some edits in other languages (through Notifications)
  • A message could be left on the unmodified article's talk page

How could it be a problem:

  • Too many notifications of this kind in low-activity wikis could create a situation in which a lot of the edits are such notifications, and they are not actually handled
  • People who make a lot of technical edits in a lot of wikis without actually knowing their languages could see a lot of unnecessary notifications, so there must be a way to opt out if it.

There could be other shortcomings, but this shouldn't be a reason not consider this feature.

Event Timeline

Perhaps first a bot can be implemented for this to see if it is being useful?

I assume edits marked as minor and or bot have to be excluded from both the initial detection and the notification purposes.

Funnily enough this would also notify about x-wiki spam/POV-pushing and such. Perhaps this can be mitigated by excluding users that are not certain something (number of edits, rights, etc.) in any of the projects they have edited.

Some common ideas are being explored in the context of Section Translation entry points (T286641).