Page MenuHomePhabricator

IABot erroneously reports zero links in article
Closed, InvalidPublic

Description

With runbotsingle on the article "Hamlet" on enwiki, with "Add archives to all non-dead references" enabled, the report comes back having run for around 22 seconds and finding 0 links (analyzed, rescued, tagged, archived: 0). The article does contain web links, both in "cite web" templates and in the form of [URL title] extlinks. Reverified several times over the last few weeks, and last a few minutes before filing this. A different article works as expected, so fairly obviously there's something about en:Hamlet that the bot chokes on (length? or maybe there's weird syntax in there somewhere?).

Event Timeline

Almost no link is inside a <ref> tag.

@Cyberpower678
Is that (must be inside <ref> tags) a requirement? Is it documented? It seems really non-intuitive that URLs inside the various cite templates (all the CS1/CS2 templates take a |url= parameter) are not checked. That would make IABot non-functional for any article that uses short citations. And what about plain extlinks?

When you check that checkbox, it is. If IABot suddenly mass added archives to all links in an article, it would cause major drama on Wikipedia.

Add archives to all non-dead **references**

  1. Edits are now made by the user running the tool and not IABot, and users are responsible for any edits they make regardless of whether they were manual or automated.
  2. Wikipedia doesn't mandate a single reference style, so short citations with full references in a separate section are by definition equally a part of the concept "references" as full references inside <ref> tags.