Page MenuHomePhabricator

Write script for Expert Reviewers to follow
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

Problem:

Evaluators need a consistent script to follow when reviewing the user interface of the Visual Editor on mobile web.

Goal:

This task is to write the script for evaluators to follow when evaluating the user interface of Visual Editor on mobile web.

Context

@aripstra and the design research team previously did a heuristic review for Visual Editor on desktop. The five tasks that they came up with were:

  1. Edit existing text
  2. Add new text
  3. Add a section heading
  4. Add a link
  5. Add a citation

This script should build upon that framework.

Event Timeline

Deskana triaged this task as Medium priority.Aug 29 2018, 9:23 AM

I posted the script as part of this process presentation and have received positive feedback.

@Deskana @Esanders - can you give it a final review and either 👎 or 👍 shipping this task? 🚢

Here's a tl;dr summary:



scenario:

When reading, I (Yankov the Knowledge Sharer) find an interesting fact, so I make an edit on my phone
I want to see the edits that I’m making in context on the article
so that I can easily share quirky facts about art.

The three tasks that experts are asked to perform are:

  1. Add a new section, add new text, format part of the text
  2. Link to another wikipedia article
  3. Add new text with a new citation

Looks good to me!

The tiniest of nitpicks: I would swap the ordering of two and three, to emphasise that generally adding citations is more important than adding links.