Page MenuHomePhabricator

Commons videos should also create .MP3s to download
Closed, DeclinedPublicFeature

Description

I'd like to have videos on commons also auto-generate .wav and .mp3 versions of the audio below each video so that I dont have to rip out audio manually for captioning. Captioning services want the audio file only to be uploaded, so having audio auto-generated would be useful.

Event Timeline

What does still require wav format nowadays?

egardner changed the subtype of this task from "Task" to "Feature Request".
egardner moved this task from To sort to Features on the TimedMediaHandler board.

What does still require wav format nowadays?

+1, the more important issue is wav is an uncompressed file format so storing wav for each audio and video may take a large amount of space.

Aklapper renamed this task from Commons videos should also create .WAV and .MP3s to download to Commons videos should also create .MP3s to download.Apr 16 2026, 9:16 AM
bvibber subscribed.

Creating .mp3 audio tracks would not be super difficult technically but I feel like this is better handled by the person who is working with the individual files they're working with who knows exactly what that individual tool requires and can create it specifically on demand using their standard tooling.

Moreover I would expect captioning services to *want* the video to provide context and wouldn't consider a divorced-audio-only-using service to be acceptable for eg content translation purposes.

I'm going to provisionally close this as "declined". If there's a very strong desire to reopen this, please provide more detail about the individual tools used and examples of how you're extracting audio and why it's problematic to do it using your own tooling.