|Open||Harej||T215354 Enable ORES RCFilters for German Wikipedia (dewiki)|
|Resolved||Ladsgroup||T215353 Audit deployments of ORES quality models and new filters|
Please don't do it for German Wikipedia. The wiki banned using ORES a while back (three or four years ago, a little bit after the Mediaviewer stuff). Deploying it without community approval first probably will cause a mayhem.
@JTannerWMF, per T164331: Define a process for adding ORES filters to new wikis when ORES is enabled on those wikis, I believe we'd decided that it is the #Growth team's responsibility to get buy-in for enabling these features since you're maintaining the UI. I'd suggest reaching out to the Wikipedians who did the most labeling work.
|User id||User name||Labels added|
|30584244||Thiemo Kreuz (WMDE)||48|
@Halfak @Ladsgroup -- @Trizek-WMF and I talked about this. Looking at @Ladsgroup's comment above about how dewiki banned ORES, it seems like the wiki would have to have a new conversation about enabling these models, facilitated by someone from WMF Community Relations. Does that sound like the appropriate next to happen? If so, we will in fact need to file a Community Relations request because Growth team wasn't expecting to add this to our to-do list in the near-term; we're currently doing a ton of community relations as we expand the help panel and newcomer homepage to more wikis. Does building the ORES models come with any validation or other materials to help the community understand how they will perform?
You can get fitness statistics directly from the service. Here's some relevant statistics for the English Wikipedia models and the German Wikipedia models.
In comparison, the German Wikipedia model fares better than the English Wikipedia model. While this comparison is hard to make directly. Surely there are different *types* of vandalism that happen in dewiki vs enwiki. But this gives a general sense that, by the numbers, it looks like the models will work well.
Also, please convey that we prioritize fixing the issues they identify in the wild. So if German Wikipedians can tell us that ORES is generally getting some type of edit wrong, we'll prioritize the work to look into that problem highly.
For clarity, I don't think ORES was ever "banned", but we did receive resistance when we first sought to document ORES on dewiki. That was back in 2014. I think *some* discussion is necessary before we do any deployment on German Wikipedia.
It looks like an old discussion was posted that suggested ORES was coming in some future iteration on RCFilters. See https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Projektdiskussion/Some_updates_about_Recent_Changes_page
It doesn't look like there was any substantial push-back at that point.