Provide more informative block error message for Special:CreateAccount
Closed, ResolvedPublic1 Estimate Story Points
Actions

Description

The error shown to a user blocked from Special:CreateAccount is less informative than other block errors:

By comparison, block messages shown when attempting to edit an article or send an email give extra details, such as the block ID for looking up the block, expiry time and whether the block is partial or sitewide.

This error uses 'cantcreateaccount-range-text' for any blocks against an IP range, and 'cantcreateaccount-text' for any other blocks (including user/IP blocks, sitewide/partial blocks, system blocks, composite blocks, etc).

Problems with this:

This message assumes that there is a single user who made the block, which is not the case for system and composite blocks
If the target is not an IP range, this message assumes that it is an IP address, leading to the confusing phrasing: "Account creation from this IP address (Blockable) [...]"
The message does not contain information specific to the block type - e.g. reassurance that partially blocked users may be able to edit other pages

In other places where a block error is shown (e.g. on the edit page), the message is chosen from several possible messages, depending on various features of the block. The error shown here should use that logic too.

Details

Related Gerrit Patches:

mediawiki/core : master

Provide a more informative message for authentication block errors

Related Objects

Mentioned In: T227174: Improve the consistency of block error notices
Mentioned Here: T189362: ipblock-exempt does not allow account creation when blocked

Event Timeline

Tchanders created this task.Jul 2 2019, 4:15 PM

Restricted Application added subscribers: MGChecker, Aklapper. · View Herald TranscriptJul 2 2019, 4:15 PM

Tchanders mentioned this in T227174: Improve the consistency of block error notices.Jul 3 2019, 8:51 AM

Niharika moved this task from Untriaged to Cards ready to be discussed on the Anti-Harassment board.Jul 11 2019, 6:34 PM

Assuming this task is about MediaWiki-User-login-and-signup and MediaWiki-User-management hence adding project tags so others can find this task under that projects.

JJMC89 moved this task from Backlog to User blocking on the MediaWiki-User-management board.Jul 20 2019, 5:43 PM

Niharika moved this task from Cards ready to be discussed to Backlog on the Anti-Harassment board.Sep 30 2019, 10:22 PM

Tchanders updated the task description. (Show Details)Oct 4 2019, 3:22 PM

Change 543875 had a related patch set uploaded (by Tchanders; owner: Tchanders):
[mediawiki/core@master] Provide a more informative message for authentication block errors

https://gerrit.wikimedia.org/r/543875

gerritbot added a project: Patch-For-Review.Oct 17 2019, 3:25 PM

Tchanders moved this task from Backlog to Cards ready to be discussed on the Anti-Harassment board.Oct 17 2019, 5:59 PM

Niharika triaged this task as Medium priority.Oct 17 2019, 6:34 PM

Niharika set the point value for this task to 1.

Niharika moved this task from Cards ready to be discussed to Cards ready for development on the Anti-Harassment board.

Niharika moved this task from Cards ready for development to The Letter Song on the Anti-Harassment board.Oct 17 2019, 7:07 PM

Niharika edited projects, added Anti-Harassment (The Letter Song); removed Anti-Harassment.

Niharika moved this task from Ready to Review on the Anti-Harassment (The Letter Song) board.

dbarratt assigned this task to Tchanders.Oct 18 2019, 9:35 PM

dbarratt moved this task from Review to QA/Testing on the Anti-Harassment (The Letter Song) board.Oct 22 2019, 5:37 PM

Change 543875 merged by jenkins-bot:
[mediawiki/core@master] Provide a more informative message for authentication block errors

https://gerrit.wikimedia.org/r/543875

Maintenance_bot removed a project: Patch-For-Review.Oct 22 2019, 6:10 PM

ReleaseTaggerBot added a project: MW-1.35-notes (1.35.0-wmf.4; 2019-10-29).Oct 22 2019, 10:00 PM

Comparing https://en.wikipedia.beta.wmflabs.org to https://test.wikipedia.org.

AuthManager

Special:CreateAccount now shows the same block error message that you see when, for example, editing while blocked. Including start of block, block expiration, intended blockee and block id.

Same on Mobile as it is on Desktop.

Creating an account via the API also shows the type of block ("blocked", "autoblocked") and the block reason as it appears on Special:CreateAccount (including the HTML tags and wikitext).

I tested that it all gets appropriately translated into the user's language.

CheckBlocksSecondaryAuthenticationProvider

If your user is ipblock-exempt but your IP is blocked from account creation, Special:CreateAccount is accessible but you are blocked from creating an account (see T189362).

Now, the block error is the same as it is on Special:CreateAccount and editing.

The API query ?action=query&list=users&usprop=cancreate&ususers=$new_user, which uses CheckBlocksSecondaryAuthenticationProvider::testUserForCreation to check whether $new_user can be created. On test returns something like:

{
    "batchcomplete": "",
    "query": {
        "users": [
            {
                "name": "Nonexistentuser123",
                "missing": "",
                "cancreateerror": [
                    {
                        "message": "cantcreateaccount-text",
                        "params": [
                            "\u202a2001:8B0:7ACF:5D4E:22CF:30FF:FE4E:1D46\u202c",
                            "{{uw-vaublock}} <!-- Username violation, vandalism-only account -->: foobar [[foo|bar]] {{anon}}",
                            "\u202aDom walden\u202c"
                        ],
                        "code": "cantcreateaccount-text",
                        "type": "error"
                    }
                ]
            }
        ]
    }
}

On beta now returns something like:

{
    "batchcomplete": "",
    "query": {
        "users": [
            {
                "name": "Nonexistentuser123",
                "missing": "",
                "cancreateerror": [
                    {
                        "message": "autoblockedtext",
                        "params": [
                            "[[User:Dom walden|\u202aDom walden\u202c]]",
                            "[[Wikipedia:Autoblock|Autoblocked]] because your IP address was recently used by \"[[User:Drwpb|Drwpb]]\". The reason given for Drwpb's block is: \"{{checkuserblock}}: jklsd fjl {{checkblock}}\".",
                            "81.187.41.249",
                            "\u202aDom walden\u202c",
                            8104,
                            "12:31, 29 October 2019",
                            "81.187.41.249",
                            "12:31, 28 October 2019"
                        ],
                        "code": "autoblocked",
                        "type": "error"
                    }
                ]
            }
        ]
    }
}

The value of the "message" parameter changing depending whether it is a partial, sitewide or autoblock.

dbarratt closed this task as Resolved.Oct 28 2019, 5:46 PM

Provide more informative block error message for Special:CreateAccountClosed, ResolvedPublic1 Estimate Story PointsActions