Section editing is enabled in mobile everywhere, so editing the lede section (section=0) should not load the whole page:
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Megan_Rapinoe#/editor/0
Section editing is enabled in mobile everywhere, so editing the lede section (section=0) should not load the whole page:
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Megan_Rapinoe#/editor/0
Subject | Repo | Branch | Lines +/- | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Pass through section=0 to VE | mediawiki/extensions/MobileFrontend | master | +3 -5 |
Status | Subtype | Assigned | Task | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Open | None | T255327 [Epic] Evaluate which editing interface should be shown by default | |||
Open | None | T227338 Test visual editor as the default mobile editor on select wikis | |||
Duplicate | • ppelberg | T221187 VE mobile default: create measurement specifications and experiment plan | |||
Resolved | nshahquinn-wmf | T221197 VE mobile default: A/B test post-deployment data checks | |||
Resolved | • ppelberg | T227897 Editing lede section in VE mobile loads the whole article |
Change 522509 had a related patch set uploaded (by Esanders; owner: Esanders):
[mediawiki/extensions/MobileFrontend@master] Pass through section=0 to VE
Change 522509 merged by jenkins-bot:
[mediawiki/extensions/MobileFrontend@master] Pass through section=0 to VE
So here are the problems if we don't do this:
Concerns if we do this:
Other questions:
Option C:
ACTION:
@ppelberg to decide between: lede/full doc/option C. Should be in time for us to make any necessary changes for the Tuesday change (i.e. end of Monday at the latest)
This statement is a very important call-out from @Esanders:
From testing, users often expect the top edit button to load the full document. Taking the user to an editor that doesn't contain the content they want is very confusing.
Is it impossible to add a section editing button to the lede (option c) while also incorporating an Edit All button that only loads on click in the toolbar?
Is it impossible to add a section editing button to the lede (option c) while also incorporating an Edit All button that only loads on click in the toolbar?
I don't think so. To clarify: "Sections" don't really exist as a thing to be added, but are inferred from the headings. so just making the desktop heading tool accessible on mobile would mean the user could create new sections before or after the current section.
We may also want to consider more guided flows (such as "add section" buttons and the start/end of the current section) or other buttons in read mode, but I don't think that would depend on an "edit all" button.
Of course, there are other use cases for "edit all" and we should consider the best way to provide that feature on T203151: Consider adding a button to let users edit the whole page in MobileFrontend.
Edit: Ignore my comment as I mis-parsed your comment about "add a section editing".
Is it impossible to add a section editing button to the lede (option c) while also incorporating an Edit All button that only loads on click in the toolbar?
To answer the question you actually asked:
I think what you are describing is a possible solution to T203151: Consider adding a button to let users edit the whole page in MobileFrontend, which I think we should address soon.
Decision
I think we should do what this task is proposing: make it so a tap on an article's top-most edit pencil will load just the lede section (section=0) instead of the entire article across all wikis.
Thinking
Resulting questions/explorations
Item | Description | Task |
A. | Revise how an article's top-most edit pencil is presented to better communicate that tapping it will open one section of article, not the whole article [2] | T228107 |
B. | Consider creating a way for contributors to navigate between article sections, while still in edit mode [3] | T228109 |
C. | Consider creating a way for contributors to edit the entire article in mobile VE [4] | T219812 |
D. | Investigate what impact moving to "all section editing" within mobile VE has? | |
After talking with @Esanders, we confirmed this patch will apply to the following:
Wikis: all
Platforms: mobile
Editing interfaces: VE (tapping an article's top-most edit pencil in mobile wikitext already default to editing the lede section of an article)