Page MenuHomePhabricator

Count of users who have a reverted suggested edit
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

Currently, the Suggested Edits feature in Android is disabled as soon as a user makes 1 edit in the app that gets reverted. The concern is that this is too strict and would unnecessarily prevent editors who generally make valuable edits from contributing via suggested edits.

Charlotte looked at background rates of reverts in the app, and has proposed setting 5 as threshold for turning off the suggested edits feature (see T231449).

To help prioritize the development needed to change the threshold, Charlotte needs to know the "Total number of unique suggested edit users with a reverted suggested edit". Are a lot of people getting impacted, or are these edge cases?

Event Timeline

kzimmerman triaged this task as Medium priority.
kzimmerman created this task.
kzimmerman moved this task from Triage to Next Up on the Product-Analytics board.

@cchen is going to take a look at this. @Dbrant, can you help out if Connie has questions about the schema?

@kzimmerman - Depends when @cchen looks at this. @Dbrant is out until the 23rd. But @Sharvaniharan can help if necessary.

This comment was removed by cchen.

By looking at timeframe: 4/23/2019 - 9/10/2019

  • Total number of unique suggested edit users with a reverted suggested edit:
Total # of users with a reverted suggested edit% of unique suggested edit users% of total unique users
1003.24% (out of 3,081)1.3% (out of 7,748)
  • Break down by edit type:
Edit Type# of users with a reverted suggested edit% of unique suggested edit users% of total unique users
image-captions893.35% (out of 2,656)3.34% (out of 2,657)
title-descriptions111.61% (out of 681)0.19% (out of 5,824)

Queries refer to suggested-edits-v2 .

@Charlotte can you review & confirm this meets your needs?

Great stuff - thanks @cchen and @kzimmerman. Oh and @JKatzWMF - here are some interesting stats for you.