Page MenuHomePhabricator

Unable to revision delete file upload comment
Closed, DuplicatePublic

Description

Files uploaded before UploadWizard would auto-generate a file "comment" based on the file text.

If the file text is later revision deleted or oversighted due to containing personal information, this comment cannot be changed without uploading a new version. It does not make sense that you cannot hide the original upload file.

File for example: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Huntley_Photography_225.JPG
Screenshot for specific context:

Event Timeline

Please note that the file linked above is not a file requiring revision deletion - it is merely an example.

As we are dealing with files (which are most often in multitudes), the option of "re-upload a file, revdel, then revert to original" is not feasible.

Additionally, I considered re-uploading the exact file so that I can revdel the older version, I cannot bypass the duplicate detection.