Page MenuHomePhabricator

RSS and Atom feeds should have an optional link= paramater to show diffs/full urls
Closed, DeclinedPublic


Author: avarab

Currently the entery for each item in the RSS looks like this:

<title>Terri Schiavo</title>
<description>more additions</description>
<pubDate>Sat, 18 Sep 2004 17:37:13 GMT</pubDate>
<comments></comments> </item>

An optional link= paramater should change the url written out in <link> to the
diff itself, in this case:


Since most people patrolling RC do so to check additions this would be much more
useful than the current feed.

Version: unspecified
Severity: enhancement



Event Timeline

bzimport raised the priority of this task from to Lowest.Nov 21 2014, 6:55 PM
bzimport set Reference to bz522.
bzimport added a subscriber: Unknown Object (MLST).

I'm actually working on including the diffs directly in the feed (currently in

The diffs in the feed are good, thanks, but not all i would hope for. The
"link=" parameter would for instance allow the feed to be used with firefox's
"life bookmarks" feature, which creates magic bookmarks from an rss feed, using
the <link> tag as the taget and the <title> tag as the label of the bookmark. I
like the idea of this feature, even though it's not so useful at the moment
because of a lack of options. But i hope it will evolve, and i would like to be
able to use it with the wikipedia.

As a temporary workaround, one could also just add a links the diff and the
history to the items content, before or after the diff itself. That saves not
only two clicks but also the time it would take to load first the article and
the the history, befor the diff is shown in the browser.

In this context, i would also like to suggest to include information about the
change in each items title. The name of the page alone is not a good title,
because the *page* is not the news, the *chane* is. Thus, the item title should
include information about the change, such as the username and the
byte-difference, similar to what is used for the IRC channel #rc.wikipedia.

This would be extremely useful for the "life bookmark" aproach, but also nice
for "real" aggregators: as it is now, a single page will appear multiple times
in the news list - frequently updated pages like logs etc will show very often.
All those entries now have the same name - which is not very useful. Titles of
the form "Article Foobar changed by User Quux, +523 bytes" would be more
informative. Maybe i should file a separate feature request for that?

myk wrote:

Given that the "Recent Changes" feed is designed to notify subscribers about
changes, it makes the most sense to link each item to the change, not the
original page. As a side-effect, it makes the feed work better with feed
readers that index items by link in the absence of ID elements uniquely
identifying each item.

myk wrote:

See also bug 3998, which is about a similar problem with the ID element.

The list shows pages, and links to pages.