Page MenuHomePhabricator

[RESEARCH SPIKE] Identify visual enhancement design questions
Open, Needs TriagePublic

Description

This task is for the thinking involved with identifying the questions [i] #Editing Design thinks will need to be answered in order to meet the following objectives:

  • Junior Contributors recognize article and user talk pages, on desktop and mobile, as places to communicate with other people on Wikipedia
  • Junior Contributors are able to successfully and confidently respond to something someone has said, start a new conversation and know when someone is talking to them on article and user talk pages, on desktop and mobile.

Research questions

  • How might we differentiate the Talk Page from the Article Page? From prior usability testing, we know that junior contributors find it challenging to make sense of the page that they are on within the context of Wikipedia. This includes more detail oriented questions such as:
  • How can we use the visual language of the page to signal to readers that this is something different than the article page?
  • Do we treat all Talk Pages the same? Or provide unique context - specific visual treatments?
  • How might we communicate to junior contributors that the Talk Page is for discussing improvements to Wikipedia and signal that it's not a forum?

Done

  • Editing Design has filled the "Research questions" section with the questions they think will need to be answered in order to deliver on the objectives described above.
    • These questions will become of the basis of the plan we will create to organize the work necessary to resolve T249579.

i. E.g. How has the visual appearance of wikitext talk pages evolved over time? What has the Wikimedia Foundation learned about how newcomers experience wikitext talk pages?

Event Timeline

ppelberg updated the task description. (Show Details)
ppelberg updated the task description. (Show Details)
ppelberg moved this task from 📚 Backlog to 📢 To Do on the Editing Design board.

Next steps

ppelberg renamed this task from Identify visual enhancement design questions to [RESEARCH SPIKE] Identify visual enhancement design questions.Sep 18 2020, 9:34 PM

@ppelberg - I updated the task description with a few starter questions..

@ppelberg - I updated the task description with a few starter questions..

Thank you for adding these, @iamjessklein.

Resulting clarification/question: I'd been thinking of the "Research questions," and this task more broadly, as being about defining the questions that will come before, what I understand to be, the more solution-oriented questions currently written in the task description.

For example, I thought the kinds of questions this task might produce and be valuable to you/us as we plan out this project could include things like:

  • "What components do all Wikipedia talk pages contain?"
  • "What components do some Wikipedia talk pages contain?"
  • "What attempts have been made in the past to make talk pages more "legible"? What impact did these changes have?

...is the above making sense?

Ah okay so I was thinking of what kinds of visual design interventions do we want to have. Taking your feedback into consideration, it might be better to think of this as an interface inventory of talk pages. I've added one more question to your list:

  • "What components do all Wikipedia talk pages contain?"
  • "What components are currently part of OOUI?"
  • "What components do some Wikipedia talk pages contain?"
  • "What attempts have been made in the past to make talk pages more "legible"? What impact did these changes have?

Removing inactive assignee. (Please reset assignees of open tasks when offboarding staff.)