Page MenuHomePhabricator

Decouple image files from type and allow replacing PNGs with SVGs in-place
Closed, DuplicatePublic

Description

Today for my first time I decided to contribute to the effort to vectorize images that are currently available only as PNGs. Unfortunately I found the experience to be excruciating and frustrating, which means I will probably not be contributing more of my work until this is addressed, because it’s simply not worth it for me emotionally to jump through so many hoops:

Problems at present

  • I cannot replace a PNG with an SVG.
  • If someone already created an SVG from a PNG, it’s hard to notice that. You have to look for a link to it on the description page, which is extremely hard to read.
  • You have to go through large numbers of articles on multiple Wikimedia projects to change all the image filenames.

Solution

Do not have file types or file extensions be part of the image upload. Make it possible for an image upload to be any file type and allow the user to replace an image with another image of a different type. This solves all of the above problems.