Page MenuHomePhabricator

Optimize personalized search results
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

Summary

Personalized search results won’t show results from the user’s reading history in certain cases.

Steps to reproduce

An example to illustrate the issue.

  • Search for the “Christopher Nolan” article and add it to a reading list
  • Open the “Jonathan Nolan” article in a new tab
  • Open the “Christopher Nolan filmography” article in a new tab and close the tab afterwards.
  • Search for “Nolan”

Expected result

“Christopher Nolan filmography” article appears as a personalized search result as it’s an article from the user’s reading history.

Actual result

“Christopher Nolan filmography” article does not appear as a personalized search result.

Event Timeline

When you open an article in a new tab (i.e. a background tab), you don't actually "visit" the article yet, so it doesn't get added to your history. With this ticket, are we proposing that articles opened in a background tab should be added to your history explicitly?

@Dbrant

When you open an article in a new tab (i.e. a background tab), you don't actually "visit" the article yet, so it doesn't get added to your history.

Open in a new tab from search opens the article in the foreground in a new tab. The described behavior actually adds the article as an item in your History.

With this ticket, are we proposing that articles opened in a background tab should be added to your history explicitly?

No, I think it’s fine as is.

Dbrant triaged this task as Medium priority.Dec 14 2020, 5:22 PM

Hi @schoenbaechler

I tried to reproduce the steps but looks like we have already changed the "Open in new tab" in search result from "open in a background tab without actually going to the article page" to actually open the article in a new tab and go to the page.

Is this ticket still valid in the current release?

Hey @cooltey — yes this is still valid, just tried it out.

This is my reading history:

Screenshot_20210610-110945.png (2×1 px, 132 KB)

And these are the search results:

Screenshot_20210610-110923.png (2×1 px, 178 KB)

As you can see, the 'Christopher Nolan filmography' article (that I visited, see reading history) is not listed as a search result when searching for 'nolan'. Why?

(the ticket is not about the 'Open' or 'Open in a new tab' behavior)

Thx for investigating!

Is this Task still relevant/open? If so I'd be interested in investigating it.

@Mr_Patoot Notice that this task is "assigned to" someone, meaning that it's being worked on currently.

Oh sorry, didn't see that. Thanks!