Page MenuHomePhabricator

Add an image: Build an iteractive prototype for Mobile Iteration 1 user testing
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

Todos

  • Create a prototype for the English version of Concept B as described in the test plan on T287758 and outlined in Figma
  • Create an English version of Concept A for testing (by cloning and customising the completed Concept B prototype)
  • Create a Spanish language version of the A & B prototypes for the Spanish user test.

Prototype:

Related Objects

StatusSubtypeAssignedTask
OpenMMiller_WMF
ResolvedRHo
ResolvedRHo
Resolvedmewoph
Resolvedmewoph
Resolvedmewoph
Resolvedmewoph
Resolvedmewoph
ResolvedRHo
ResolvedRHo
ResolvedRHo
Resolvedmewoph
Resolvedmewoph
Duplicatekostajh
ResolvedRHo
Resolvedkostajh
ResolvedRHo
ResolvedRHo
DeclinedRHo
Resolvedmewoph
ResolvedRHo

Event Timeline

RHo updated the task description. (Show Details)
RHo updated the task description. (Show Details)

Posting issues found by @MMiller for posterity:

IssueStatus & Notes
Concept A / both platforms: some of the topics in the topic dialog are showing up like “% - topic_food”. see screenshot below.Fixed.
Both concepts / iPhone SE: I can’t swipe down far enough to see the whole explanation of the task — all my attempted swipes just slide the suggestion one way or another.Open. This seems to be a known issue with older iOS devices. @RHo tried to fix by adding -webkit-overflow-scrolling: touch; but it doesn’t work on the simulator.
Both concepts / both platforms: “skip” doesn’t do anything.Won’t fix. We don’t want people to skip during the unmoderated test but the colour was updated to be a lighter Base20.
Both concepts / both platforms: “close to view changes” doesn’t do anything.Won’t fix. For this unmoderated test, we don’t want people to get lost in the post-edit article.
Concept A / both platforms: after rejection, the banner still says “You’ve published an edit!” instead of “Thanks for reviewing suggestions!”Fixed by @kostajh on https://github.com/reetssydney/prototypes/pull/22
Concept A / both platforms: the edit summary screen doesn’t show an image thumbnail, but Concept B does.Fixed.
Concept B / iPhone SE: after tapping “yes”, my focus doesn’t end up on the caption — it goes to the top of the article and the caption is below the fold.Unsure. I could not reproduce this on my iPhone 11 simulator.
Concept B / iPhone SE: if I tap “yes”, then go back, and then tap “yes” again, the images start to stack up.  Also sometimes the image metadata goes away from the image card.  See screenshots below.Open I can reproduce the images stacking up on the add caption step (it's when you tap back and then yes again) but may not fix in time. Cannot, however, reproduce the error with the metadata not showing.
Both concepts / Samsung A21: the sixth suggestion takes several seconds to show up in the feed when I swipe over to it.I reduced the filesize which should fix this.
Not sure which concepts / not sure which platforms: sometimes the onboarding would show up for each new task, and sometimes it only showed up for the first task in my session.Did not fix. The onboarding is considered “done” only if you click the checkmark to close it on the 3rd tip. I don’t think it’s worthwhile to fiddle with further at this point, but added a note to the instruction to make close by clicking the blue button with the tick.
Concept B - Empty metadata
image.png (1×782 px, 356 KB)
Concept B - Multiple images added
image.png (1×804 px, 1 MB)