Page MenuHomePhabricator

Duplicated file ending after cropping; unneeded plural in string; unneeded notification message; non-updated upload comment after editing file
Closed, InvalidPublic

Description

Feedback Link: https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Topic:Wamlxg2qpvh08oa0

Feedback:

Hello!

Thanks for great work with VideoCutTool. I tried to crop c:File:Alhambra.3.ogv but I found a few errors: When you crop and preview, the file name options are weird. If you choose to upload as a new file "Alhambra_(edited).ogv.ogv" is the suggested title. The "3" in the original filename is removed for some reason and the file extension is doubled. If you choose to overwrite the original file instead, the filename "Alhambra.ogv.ogv" is suggested. This obviously differs from the original filename and the application therefore doesn't go through with the overwriting and a red notification box instead appears with the text "Something went wrong". Despite that, this is still rendered: "Your New Videos will be here: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Alhambra.ogv.ogv". I suggest that message doesn't appear if the upload doesn't work. Also why is video in the plural? Maybe it should be changed to the singular?

Also, why is the upload comment identical to the one that the original file had? Maybe it should be changed to something like "Cropped/Trimmed/Rotated/Removed audio from EXAMPLE.EXT"?

Don't take this as critizism. I do appreciate the tool and effort put into it, I just wanted to make you awere of the issues :).

Event Timeline

Best to summarize in the task title, otherwise you end up with lots of indistinguishable tickets all called "user feedback".
This should be split into separate tasks, to cover only one topic per task. That will allow to have more specific task summaries which allows distinguishing when looking at a list of tasks, and it will also allow to track the progress and status of each topic. Hence I am closing this current task as invalid. Thanks.

Aklapper renamed this task from User feedback on VideoCutTool talk page to Duplicated file ending after cropping; unneeded plural in string; unneeded notification message; non-updated upload comment after editing file.Sep 28 2021, 7:06 PM
Aklapper closed this task as Invalid.