Page MenuHomePhabricator

Verify Automatic Topic Subscriptions are enabled in expected ways
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

T294398 changed how Automatic Topic Subscription is configured such that only new accounts become automatically subscribed to the discussions they start and comment within.

This task is about verifying the above has been implemented in as we expect.

Test cases

  • On wikis where Automatic Topic Subscriptions is available by default (read: the functionality is available regardless of the state of the Discussion tools Beta Feature):
    • New people/accounts should see the Automatically subscribe to topics setting within Special:Preferences#mw-prefsection-editing --> Discussion pages ENABLED
    • Existing account holders should see the Automatically subscribe to topics setting within Special:Preferences#mw-prefsection-editing --> Discussion pages DISABLED

This chart is an attempt to communicate the requirements listed above in a more visual way...

Availability of Automatic Topic SubscriptionsAutomatically subscribe to topics setting (EXISTING accounts)Automatically subscribe to topics setting (NEW accounts)
Opt-outDISABLEDENABLED

Wikis to test on

Any of the wikis listed in T304027.

Done

  • Verify the Automatic Topic Subscriptions setting is configured in the ways described in the ===Test cases section above

Event Timeline

@ppelberg The “visual” and the “non-visual” description in the description contradict (the “visual” says DISABLED for both new and existing accounts, the “non-visual” one says ENABLED for new accounts and DISABLED only for existing accounts). Please edit the description to make it consistent.

@ppelberg The “visual” and the “non-visual” description in the description contradict (the “visual” says DISABLED for both new and existing accounts, the “non-visual” one says ENABLED for new accounts and DISABLED only for existing accounts). Please edit the description to make it consistent.

Good spot; I think "visual" and "non-visual" descriptions should now be consistent. Thank you for saying something, @Tacsipacsi.

EAkinloose subscribed.

✅ Verify Automatic Topic Subscriptions are enabled in expected ways

wikiAvailability of Automatic Topic SubscriptionsAutomatically subscribe to topics setting (EXISTING accounts)Automatically subscribe to topics setting (NEW accounts)
bnwikOpt-outDISABLED
Screenshot 2022-08-26 at 03.10.19.png (1×1 px, 228 KB)
ENABLED
Screenshot 2022-09-26 at 17.24.57.png (1×2 px, 368 KB)
zhwikOpt-outDISABLED
Screenshot 2022-08-26 at 03.09.41.png (1×1 px, 209 KB)
ENABLED
Screenshot 2022-09-26 at 17.32.33.png (1×1 px, 226 KB)

✅ Verify Automatic Topic Subscriptions are enabled in expected ways

@EAkinloose the screenshots you shared in T300904#8187501 lead me to think that new accounts on zh.wiki and bn.wiki do NOT have automatic topic subscriptions enabled for them by default...am I interpreting those screenshots accurately?

If so, then I don't think this functionality is working in the way we expect it to....

✅ Verify Automatic Topic Subscriptions are enabled in expected ways

@EAkinloose the screenshots you shared in T300904#8187501 lead me to think that new accounts on zh.wiki and bn.wiki do NOT have automatic topic subscriptions enabled for them by default...am I interpreting those screenshots accurately?

If so, then I don't think this functionality is working in the way we expect it to....

Sorry about that @ppelberg . It works fine. The attached screenshots was a mistake on my part.
I have updated the comment with a recent screenshot from testing this today.

Thanks!

I have updated the comment with a recent screenshot from testing this today.

The new files aren’t publicly visible. 🙁 Could you please click File Not Attached for these two files in the Referenced files section in the upper right corner and attach the files so that they become public? Thanks in advance!

ppelberg claimed this task.