Looks like status is already taken as a name for a template: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vorlage:Status

Any suggestions for a different naming @JStrodt_WMDE ?

Maybe "Status Karte" similar to https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vorlage:Status_Sportler?

Maybe "Status Karte" similar to https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vorlage:Status_Sportler?

Yes, good idea.

"Status Karte" makes the template less re-usable for other projects though. Would "Vorlage:Zustand" fit? Or is it weird german?

Good point, @ECohen_WMDE
Zustand is maybe a little bit weird. How about Fortschritt?

Fortschritt it is. :)

@ECohen_WMDE Could you upload the images so we do not get into licence/ownership troubles? :)

Part 1 looks great, @lilients_WMDE!
Is it possible to always add a blank space behind the circle? Right now, if you place the template on the page directly before the text, it looks very crammed.
https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benutzerin:Johanna_Strodt_(WMDE)/Kartensaison/Kartenwünsche#Die_Wunschliste

Is it possible to always add a blank space behind the circle? Right now, if you place the template on the page directly before the text, it looks very crammed. https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benutzerin:Johanna_Strodt_(WMDE)/Kartensaison/Kartenwünsche#Die_Wunschliste

I am not sure how we want this template to be used. We could for example also want users to add only the icon at the end of a sentences. In that case the blank space after the icon might look strange.

We could also think about making it possible to add the name of the wikipage as an (optional) parameter and then automatically add a blank space. Something like this: {{Fortschritt|offen|Artikel}} (Kommentar) ~~~~. Not sure that is necessary though.

The simplest solution would be to add the blank space to the "Kopiervorlage" just the way it is now:

• {{Fortschritt|offen}} [[Artikel]] (Kommentar) ~~~~

The simplest solution would be to add the blank space to the "Kopiervorlage" just the way it is now:

OK, got it. That seems to be the most sensible approach, IMHO.

As far as I am concerned, you can go ahead and migrate the template from your user page to the real Vorlage: namespace.

As far as I am concerned, you can go ahead and migrate the template from your user page to the real Vorlage: namespace.

✅ https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vorlage:Fortschritt

• Count number of templates per status ...

✅ https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benutzer:Svantje_Lilienthal_(WMDE)/Test

• Count number of templates ... (excluding those in the example) ...

To prevent the examples from being counted, I would put them (or the actual list) in a separate page. Is that ok @JStrodt_WMDE?

Thanks for making this work on the Kartensaison start page as well! <3

I noticed that the alignment is a bit off at times:

Can this be fixed? Pinging @ECohen_WMDE in case their input is needed.

Also, one of the community members who tested the page told me they always want to click on the circles and are always confused that that doesn't work. Is there a simple way to link the circles on the start page to the page /Kartenwünsche?

Ideally there could be a nonbreaking space between the number circle and the label, so when they stack on smaller screens the two move together as a unit. That would help avoid this problem.

Another critical difference from my mocks and the current display is that the text is on two lines so that it takes up less width. Is this possible to give the text less space, forcing it to wrap?

Lastly, it was definitely an oversight not to show a mobile version. Can they all stack with 20px padding between and all left aligned?

If these suggestions don't work, let me know what the constraints are and I can help adjust the design so that it works responsively.

Thanks for making this work on the Kartensaison start page as well! <3

You are welcome! ❤

I noticed that the alignment is a bit off at times.

T308843#7956029

Good catches! As this is also connected to T308848, maybe @WMDE-Fisch we can look into that together?

Also, one of the community members who tested the page told me they always want to click on the circles and are always confused that that doesn't work. Is there a simple way to link the circles on the start page to the page /Kartenwünsche?

Sure you can simply add a surrounding link. Is that sufficient?

It does change the styling though. It is now styled as a link. Maybe that is ok, because it actually is a link, @ECohen_WMDE? 🤔

Sure you can simply add a surrounding link. Is that sufficient?

That looks much better than expected! But I'd also love to hear @ECohen_WMDE's thoughts on that.

I created a subpage that includes an updated version of the circles with the line brakes and I added a link to the description each.

I created a subpage that includes an updated version of the circles with the line brakes and I added a link to the description each.

Looking good! And yes if they are a link, they should look like links - so that's fine. Do they all link to the same place?

Looking good! And yes if they are a link, they should look like links - so that's fine. Do they all link to the same place?

Nice! Currently, the link at the same place, but we can easily change that, when we have sections for each status later.

Due to user feedback, I moved the new template Fortschritt back to my user name space. We should look for a better place though. Alternatively we could also use these existing templates: Vorlage:Diskussionsbausteine (as suggested by the user).

@JStrodt_WMDE & @ECohen_WMDE, what would you prefer?

Tech review:

• Thanks for including an inline example for each template!
• The circle template needs some CSS tweaks to be immune to font size and zoom,

at 67% zoom:

• Circle should include a default color e.g. gray, to help debug when the user hasn't provided the correct farbe parameter, for example. Default and fallback parameter values usually look like this: {{{farbe|{{{color|#666666}}}}}}
• Fortschritt circles should probably scale as the page zooms. As an extreme example, I zoom in to 300% to see if the yellow circle has something in it or if my monitor is dirty, and:

• The search is too strict. For example, search=Fortschritt{{!}}offen will fail against {{Fortschritt | offen. According to these docs, zero or more whitespaces should be matched by %s*.
• The "ampel" is nicely responsive, but needs a bit of vertical padding:

Thanks @awight for the review! 🕶 I adjusted the pages accordingly. ✅