Page MenuHomePhabricator

Exploration: Redesign the Wikinews logo to increase recognition at small sizes
Closed, DeclinedPublic

Description

Background

  • Description: the current Wikinews logo is too detailed and it should be simplified to be more readable on small sizes (e.g. favicon).
  • History: the need for this redesign was discussed in T314661#8556745
  • Known use case(s): describe known use cases for this icon, including the project and team where you will use this icon (and timeline if needed)

User stories

  • As a user, I need the Wikinews logo and icon to be readable on any size.

Considerations (Optional)

Redesigning a Wikimedia project icon would have to include community alignment on the problem, community liaisons and Comms dept to agree and follow along too. Note, this is currently only a design exploration task to clarify problem statement and sketch early ideas.

Open questions (Optional)

Goal

The goal is to simplify the current Wikinews icon to remove the "soundwaves" to be more like the favicon seen on Commons.

Captura de Pantalla 2023-01-25 a las 16.52.31.png (614×1 px, 232 KB)

Design spec

Once the icon spec sheet has been created, the Figma file should be included here.

SVG icon

Once the icon has been created, we will export it in SVG format and add it here.

Acceptance criteria for Done

Design

  • The design of the new logo and icon is ready
  • The new icon has been reviewed with help from the DST (and community if needed)
  • The icon is recognizable on low DPI resolutions
  • The icon has been exported as an optimized SVG and added to this task’s description
  • The new icon has been included in our Icon System Figma file, and the library has been published

Code

  • Add icon in Codex
  • Add icon in OOUI
  • Replace the current Wikinews logo with this new one

Documentation

Event Timeline

Restricted Application triaged this task as High priority. · View Herald TranscriptJan 25 2023, 3:55 PM
Restricted Application added a subscriber: Aklapper. · View Herald Transcript

@RHo @Volker_E I've started working on this Figma exploration file to redesign the Wikinews logo and icon with @KieranMcCann and define the best possible solution.

Some explorations for the new logo have been captured in this Figma file by @KieranMcCann and me.

This is a simplified representation of the current Wikinews logo.

Captura de Pantalla 2023-01-30 a las 15.36.48.png (404×1 px, 286 KB)

We could also simplify the logo by using another simple representation of "world".

Captura de Pantalla 2023-01-30 a las 15.37.22.png (398×396 px, 149 KB)

Do we want to simplify the current logo as much as possible (I mean, using the same shape of lines) or could we simplify the world by using another symbol? cc: @RHo @Volker_E

I think these seem fine. It may make sense to ping Wikinews community so people with vested interest can give their input.
It would also make sense to provide some examples about where these icons will be shown and see the options in-situ at the 20x20px size.

Volker_E renamed this task from Redesign the Wikinews logo and icon to Exploration: Redesign the Wikinews logo to increase recognition at small sizes.Jan 30 2023, 7:22 PM
Volker_E lowered the priority of this task from High to Lowest.
Volker_E updated the task description. (Show Details)

The pure performance issue of the too detailed Wikinews and Wiktionary icons is now handled in T328492.

Declining this task since we will work in T328492. We will reopen this task in the future if needed.