Page MenuHomePhabricator

We prioritise article level over section level image suggestions for unillustrated articles in notifications for ECs
Closed, DeclinedPublic

Description

Context

We only suggest article level image suggestions for unillustrated articles. But we generate and will serve section level image suggestions for both, illustrated and unillustrated articles. It might mean that, if we send out an image suggestion notifications for a section of an unillustrated article without or before a page level image suggestion for the same article (if exists) and an EC adds it, the article will be flagged as illustrated during the next dataset update and thus excluded from article level image suggestion pipeline.

This will mean that it would never be suggested for a page level illustration and would not provide a good content experience (Note that based on SLIS evaluations it seems that it happens rarely that an article does not have a lead image but only has a section image).

As an experienced contributor, I don't want to get a notification for illustrating a section of unillustrated article before or without also an article level image suggestions if exists.

AC

  • For a given unillustrated article, the article level image suggestion, if exists, is sent in a notification before or together with any potential section level image suggestions.

Event Timeline

As we have no API, we (SD) have no control over how the data is read, only how it is written

We don't want to not store recommendations if we have them, so instead we'll have to enforce the above rule on the client side (i.e. our notifcations code, and in Growth's code)

After aligning with Cormac, we can put this ticket back in the backlog and I will change the description to represent that we want to do it for notifications. I will separately bring it with Kirsten a suggestion for filtering out unillustrated articles for getting section level image suggestions.

AUgolnikova-WMF renamed this task from Article image suggestion is prioritised over section image suggestion for unillustrated articles to We prioritise article level over section level image suggestions for unillustrated articles in notifications for ECs.Mar 1 2023, 3:36 PM
AUgolnikova-WMF updated the task description. (Show Details)

The AC is added as a requirement to the "Send notifications" ticket T330934 as discussed during grooming. Closing this one and adding a link in T330934 to this ticket for reference