Page MenuHomePhabricator

Positive Reinforcement: Personalized praise design improvements for revert data
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

As a Mentor, I want see a mentee's revert data, because I need to know that before I consider sending praise.

Background

In a Community consultation about Personalized Praise ideas, some mentors mentioned that they would prefer being able to see the number of reverts the newcomer had received:

I’d like to customize how many reverts the newcomer can have. Zero is too little – I’ve seen newcomers creating a nearly-perfect article, while still having few edits reverted.
I don't have enough information (like reverts) to make a decision to send praise

The personalized praise idea is part of a larger Growth team Positive Reinforcement effort.

Proposed design

We will be adding a new scorecard with the number of reverted edits a newcomer has. This scorecard is using the editUndo icon.

Personalized praise_ Revert data (1).png (517×448 px, 36 KB)

Acceptance Criteria:

Given I'm a mentor viewing my Mentor dashboard,
When I have a praiseworthy mentee,
Then there is some indication of reverts (revert total or revert ratio)

Given I'm a mentor viewing my Mentor dashboard,
When I adjust my "Send praise" settings,
Then I can adjust how many edits a newcomer can have (within the selected time frame) and still be considered praiseworthy

Event Timeline

From the latest Ambassadors meeting, revert data should be displayed.

It is interesting to see how newcomers behave; it saves time in deciding to praise them as too many reverts can characterize a bad user.
It is an expected metric. and we should provide a filter for reverts.
We can have the case of users who start with one vandalism, to taste the water; some of them are now key community members. However, these users would continue, with no praise, as it is now.

KStoller-WMF renamed this task from Positive Reinforcement: Personalized Praise - Revert data to Positive Reinforcement: Personalized praise design improvements for revert data.Apr 27 2023, 5:30 PM
KStoller-WMF assigned this task to JFernandez-WMF.
KStoller-WMF triaged this task as Medium priority.
KStoller-WMF updated the task description. (Show Details)

@Trizek-WMF, @Urbanecm_WMF: Hello! What are your thoughts on this approach for Revert data? We would use the Impact Module scorecard designs (so Martin, if we go with this approach, no need to change the Personalized praise module that much :)). We would have a new scorecard with the number of reverted edits the newcomer has. Happy to hear your feedback on this or if you have any other ideas. Thanks!

Personalized praise_ Revert data (1).png (517×448 px, 36 KB)

I have updated the task description with the proposed design. Closing this task as Resolved after a round of feedback with Product and Growth Ambassadors!