Page MenuHomePhabricator

Personalized praise: Evaluate leading indicators
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

User story & summary:

As the Growth team, I want to quickly determine if the Personalized praise features are being used and having a positive impact on newcomers because if we see any negative impact then we will want to revert changes and if we don't see any positive changes then we will need to make further improvements or consider sunsetting the features.

Questions

Short term questions:

  • What is the number of messages sent from mentor to mentee?
  • What is the number of messages sent from mentor to mentee that were initiated from the “Send praise” button on the mentor dashboard?
  • What is the number of messages sent from mentor to mentee that were not initiated from the “Send praise” button on the mentor dashboard.
  • What percent of mentees who are surfaced as praiseworthy are receiving a message from their mentor?
  • What percent of notifications received by mentors are being clicked on
  • Out of all of the messages sent through the “Send appreciation” feature, what proportion are positive/encouraging?

Long-term questions:

  • Is there a difference in activity and retention for the group of newcomers who have mentors with the Personalize praise features vs. the group that doesn't have mentorship.
Experiment plan
IndicatorExpected resultPlan of action
Mentorship + Personalized Praise notification click throughAt least 10% of Mentors who view a Personalised praise notification click on itIf this number is much lower than the click through on other notifications, then we should investigate if there are technical issues or an issue with the language used.
Mentorship + Personalized Praise mentor dashboard module click throughAt least 10% of Mentors who view a Personalised praise suggestion on their Mentor dashboard end up clicking through to send praiseIf this threshold is met then we should investigate if there are technical issues or an issue with how Mentors are interpreting this call to action.
Acceptance Criteria:
  • Work with the Product Manager and Growth team to establish leading indicators for [new features]
  • Document leading indicators on the Positive Reinforcement page
  • Post MVP launch of the Personalized praise features, evaluate and record a summary of leading indicator results on [project page]
  • Share summary of findings with the Growth team

Event Timeline

KStoller-WMF created this task.

Blocked until Personalized praise notifications are released / T334630: Personalized praise: Deployment of the new mentor dashboard module to Growth Pilot Wikis is complete.

@nettrom_WMF Just FYI, I'm moving this out of unblocked since the remainder of the Personalized praise work was just released: T334630: Personalized praise: Deployment of the new mentor dashboard module to Growth Pilot Wikis.

Hopefully we can look at some initial leading indicators as soon as next week?

@nettrom_WMF Just FYI, I'm moving this out of unblocked since the remainder of the Personalized praise work was just released: T334630: Personalized praise: Deployment of the new mentor dashboard module to Growth Pilot Wikis.

Hopefully we can look at some initial leading indicators as soon as next week?

I've moved it to the Product Analytics kanban board and put it in "Ready for development" on the Growth team's board since it's now ready for me to pick up.

Scheduled this for late next week as we'll then have about a week's worth of data to analyze across all three schemas after I verified that the first hour of data for the interaction schema was 2023-05-24. The other schemas have more data, so I might start work on it a little earlier.

@nettrom_WMF - we discussed separately, but also adding a note here that we'll have ~25 minutes of team meeting time next Tuesday (June 13th) to discuss initial leading indicators for Personalized praise.

KStoller-WMF closed this task as Resolved.EditedJun 16 2023, 7:33 PM
KStoller-WMF updated the task description. (Show Details)

I've checked off acceptance criteria.
Results were presented to the team, and I've added a summary here:
https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Growth/Positive_reinforcement#Personalized_praise_4