Page MenuHomePhabricator

Growth: Scale Personalized Praise features to all Wikipedias
Open, MediumPublic

Description

Research shows that praise and encouragement from other users increases newcomer retention. We want to think about how to encourage experienced users to thank and award newcomers for good contributions. Perhaps mentors could be encouraged to do this on their mentor dashboards or through notifications. We can utilize existing communication mechanisms which past studies have proven to have a degree of positive effect.

The personalized praise idea is part of a larger Growth team Positive Reinforcement effort.


User story & summary:

As a New Editor, I want to get feedback & encouragement, so that I feel part of a the community and can assess how I'm doing.
As a Mentor, I want to encourage mentees that show promise, because then they are more likely to be retained.

Background & research:

The Leveling up features focus on encouraging newcomers to progress to more valuable tasks. Ideas also include some prompts for new editors to try suggested edits, since structured tasks have been shown to improve newcomer activation and retention.

Acceptance Criteria:

Release Personalized Praise features to all remaining Wikipedias that have Growth features.

NOTE: these features will only impact wikis that have Mentorship enabled, but the Personalized praise features should be available in Community configuration for any wiki that enables Mentorship.
  • set release date (once this task is claimed, communicate with @Trizek-WMF & @KStoller-WMF)
  • @Trizek-WMF to inform communities & ensure they are aware of Community Configuration options
  • enable Leveling up on all Wikipedias that have Growth features (no A/B testing needed)
  • Disable A/B test on pilot wikis

Event Timeline

KStoller-WMF removed KStoller-WMF as the assignee of this task.
KStoller-WMF triaged this task as Medium priority.
KStoller-WMF moved this task from Inbox to Blocked on the Growth-Team board.

Note: this task is currently blocked by the completion of experiment analysis: T341387: Mentorship + Personalized Praise: Analysis.

@KStoller-WMF Is this task still blocked by the completion of the experiment analysis?

@DMburugu - Thanks for the reminder to update this task.
No, this task is not blocked by the completion of the experiment analysis. Experiment analysis is complete and published here:
https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Growth/Positive_reinforcement#Personalized_praise_experiment_results

However, as noted in those results:

As these results were not positive enough to justify the time investment from Mentors, we have decided to start conversations with our ambassadors and communities and consider further improvements before releasing the feature more widely. We will consider improvements related to reducing the amount of work needed by Mentors, potential design improvements, and improvements to how newcomers are selected to be displayed in the Personalized praise module.

I've added the feedback from Mentors on our pilot wikis here: T361763#9779083

I'll update this task to fit under this epic: T361763: [EPIC] Positive Reinforcement: second iteration of Personalized Praise .

As of now, we've discussed attempting to fit in a Mentorship + Personalized Praise sprint in Q1 next fiscal year. And if we can't find time to fit in that work, then we should consider disabling the Personalized Praise features.