Page MenuHomePhabricator

Article is marked as reviewed despite no log entries since move from draftspace
Open, Needs TriagePublicBUG REPORT

Description

The enwiki article Sigma male is marked as reviewed in Special:NewPagesFeed, despite not having any PageTriage log entries since its move from draftspace. It seems that either a log entry wasn't created when it should have been, or the page was marked as reviewed when it shouldn't have been.

Page review history (as far as I can see)

  • A redirect at the title "Sigma male" was created in August 2021, and was automatically reviewed by DannyS712 bot III (and then again by 'zinbot, after being nominated at RfD in November).
  • In May 2022, the redirect was converted into an article. It was later turned back into a redirect, and then marked as reviewed, by MarioGom.
  • In July 2022, the redirect was again converted into an article. A revision was marked as a potential copyright violation by EranBot, and the (now-article) was marked as reviewed by Alexandermcnabb later in the month.
  • In September 2023, the now-article was blanked-and-redirected by GorillaWarfare.
  • In March 2024, the mainspace redirect was pageswapped with a draftspace page of the same name by Queen of Hearts (who is not autopatrolled).

Because of the page-swap, the log entries for the page "Sigma male" prior to March 2024 relate to the previous page (now moved to Draft:Sigma male), rather than the current page.

Event Timeline

Noting that this article appears to have been "patrolled" as opposed to "reviewed" see this query

Actually, just kidding. T337356: Moving a page marks the resulting redirect as patrolled but not reviewed is about the resulting redirect, not the article. Hmm.

I did some localhost testing just now and was not able to reproduce this with simple moves. Simple moves from an admin account without autopatrol, moving from draftspace to mainspace, resulted in an article that showed up in Special:NewPagesFeed. I did this both with a really old draft (over 90 days) and a really new draft (just created).

I think the next step is to use a sysop=false, extendedmover=false, patroller=true account, install the page swap script, and try it then in a localhost environment. I suspect the page move script is doing something unusual and the bug will hopefully be reproducible and debuggable in that workflow.