Page MenuHomePhabricator

refuse page protection in MediaWiki: namespace
Closed, DeclinedPublicFeature

Description

Feature summary
If a page is in namespace 8 = MediaWiki an attempt to modify protection should be refused.

  • Perhaps some superprotect or other more-than-sysop people can be imagined, but no case is known.

Use case(s)

  • By good faith, recently a sysop tried to lower access to a system message
  • Subsequently and correct, pageinfo reported that individual protection is in effect. Yes, it is, but overruled by generic MediaWiki: block.

Benefits

  • Immediately blocking of pointless attempts.
  • Avoid confusion in pageinfo.

Event Timeline

"

Perhaps some superprotect or other more-than-sysop people can be imagined, but no case is known.

"

Not true. One wiki I know that deliberately uses this is https://publictestwiki.com

Bugreporter subscribed.

Decline this since https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Manual:Administrators#Protection explicitly states MediaWiki namespace restriction will work in addition to protection.