Page MenuHomePhabricator

Enhance search within Citoid's "Re-use" tab
Closed, InvalidPublic

Description

This task involves the work of enhancing the search function within Citoid's "Re-use" tab to enable people to search full URLs.

Behavior

  1. Edit a Wikipedia article using the visual editor (e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warrnambool)
  2. Open Citoid
  3. Navigate to the Re-use tab
  4. Search for a specific URL (e.g. https://search.worldcat.org/title/54913331 or search.worldcat.org/title/54913331)

Current

  1. No results appear

🟢 Desired

  1. The following result appears:
Clark, Ian D. (2002). Dictionary of Aboriginal placenames of Victoria. Heydon, Toby, 1972-, Victorian Aboriginal Corporation for Languages. Melbourne: Victorian Aboriginal Corp. for Languages. ISBN 0-9579360-2-8. OCLC 54913331.

References

Event Timeline

Restricted Application added a subscriber: Aklapper. · View Herald Transcript

I don't see any re-use tab, could you clarify? How should the source appear if it does not have that URL? If it's linked to the URL, it already shows up when you ctrl+f search in the wikitext editor.

The reuse tab in citoid
image.png (912×904 px, 216 KB)
It failing to find that URL
image.png (844×908 px, 83 KB)
It finding the URL that's actually in the citation
image.png (854×896 px, 187 KB)

So, issue here is that they're attempting to search for a URL that Citoid would actually turn into that citation... but which isn't the URL that's used in the generated citation.

Actually, Citoid wouldn't turn either URL into that citation. 🤷🏻

Actually, Citoid wouldn't turn either URL into that citation. 🤷🏻

Mmm. Warrnambool was my contrived example. I didn't realise that I was searching for a different url than in the wikicode. I am guessing that after citoid was used to insert the cite in 2001
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Warrnambool&oldid=1005705998) the website's url structure changed and they starting redirecting. I just asked on Wish linked above if the original user can provide an example from Google books for their jawiki use case.

If it is a case of websites updating their urls, I cannot see how citoid's search can be enhanced. This task may be invalid.

I am not 100% familiar with Phabricator, but I have marked the task as invalid. The task description is based on a false premise (formulated from my misunderstanding). The title Enhance search within Citoid's "Re-use" tab is very general and the description and dsicussion did not apply.