Page MenuHomePhabricator

Mobile Web - Implement subscription alert
Closed, DuplicatePublicFeature

Description

Feature summary Editor participation in ongoing discussions is vital to the project, and this should be regardless of whether the user is desktop or mobile based. As things stand, mobile users receive alerts to topics of interest via the red bell at the top of the screen. However, although mobile users are invited to "subscribe" to a topic on Talk pages, Village Pump, etc., they are not subsequently alerted to new posts on that topic, which is a shortfall on their expressed expectation.

Use case(s)

  1. Subscribe to a discussion topic (for example a recent new Village Pump discussion).
  2. After there have been further posts to that topic, viewing desktop screens (on Wikipedia, Wikidata, Commons, Meta) flags the active discussion in "Your notices" at the top of the screen.
  3. However, switching to the equivalent mobile web screen shows no such flagging on the bell at the top of the screen. The user is left unaware of the progressing discussion, but if they click on the bell anyway, the screen will properly summarise the discussion activity on the Notifications screen.

Benefits Including the subscribed topic activity in the same way as other alerted activity would enhance equity of service to desktop and mobile users, improving opportunity for conversation engagement.

Event Timeline

I believe that this task may be looking for the same outcome/have the same underlying issue as T344029: Notification counter not shown on mobile (Minerva) when the user has no unseen alerts - are there any objections if it’s merged into that one?

I believe that this task may be looking for the same outcome/have the same underlying issue as T344029: Notification counter not shown on mobile (Minerva) when the user has no unseen alerts - are there any objections if it’s merged into that one?

Mmm, they do look like two similar situations. I considered raising this one as a Bug, but eventually decided it may be more of a Feature Enhancement; that said, for both Thanks and a topic Subscription, a user has requested something which is being under-delivered.

Without knowing whether Thanks and topic subscription notifications involve distinct data stores,, the issue can perhaps be generalised to: If there are any Notifications waiting for a user, the Minerva Bell icon should be highlighted.

“Notice” is the Echo term for everything that appears in the menu with the drawer-like icon on desktop: this includes thanks, people linking to pages one created, edit milestones, and yes, topic subscriptions as well. So given that the title of the other task speaks about notices in general, it’s indeed a duplicate.