Page MenuHomePhabricator

[Epic] [WE 1.2] Activity Tab Experiment
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Assigned To
Authored By
HNordeenWMF
Apr 15 2025, 4:28 PM
Referenced Files
F59651424: IMG_616EAABF0690-1.jpeg
May 3 2025, 7:13 PM
F59651397: IMG_7B49C4F0B653-1.jpeg
May 3 2025, 7:13 PM
F59282589: image.png
Apr 17 2025, 5:15 PM
F59245628: image.png
Apr 15 2025, 6:03 PM
F59245604: Screenshot 2025-04-09 at 4.36.28 PM.png
Apr 15 2025, 6:03 PM

Description

Tasks

Build off prototype from offsite

  • Localization (put strings into Translate Wiki for volunteers to translate ASAP) - T392010
  • Adjust components to match new wireframes - T392011
  • Connect Logged-out screen - T392027
  • Get editing count working - T392028
  • Add navigation to saved articles tab - T392033
  • Add editing empty state - T392035
  • Add suggested edits component - T392036
  • Add survey (using YiR Component): Are you satisfied with your "Activity" screen? What else would you like to see here in the future? - T392297
  • Design touch ups (iPhone portrait only, do not need to optimize for landscape or iPad) -
  • Wrap up in 30-day A/B/C test: see details below
  • Instrumentation T392248
  • Add link to edit history T392164 (nice to have)
Background

In a recent study on Editing and Reading on the iOS App, we saw that notifications about edit counts and activity related to their contributions were motivating for some new editors. One experienced editor also mentioned feeling encouraged by seeing their edit count on the desktop version. But, unstructured editing on the iOS app requires using Wikitext, which is intimidating to most newcomers.

We know from our recent experiences with Year in Review that viewing insights is motivating for both readers and editors, and that folks are willing to create an account to have access to them.

We want to learn if immediately providing a structured way to edit (via “Add an image”), and immediately providing edit activity statistics helps newcomers on the iOS App activate at a higher rate.

Hypothesis
If we temporarily present a population of new account holders with an invitation to add an image via Suggested Edits within an Activity tab, we'll learn if this explicit call to action, and corresponding structured workflow, is ≥25% more effective at increasing constructive activation than a generic invitation to "Edit" Wikipedia presented in the same place.

How will we know we were successful
  • Validation
    • KR 1.1 Users in the experiment group C with access to Add an image in their activity tab have a 25% higher constructive activation rate compared to those in group B who did not have access
      • Fallback: KR 1.1 Users in the experiment group C with access to Add an image in their activity tab have a 25% higher activation rate compared to group B
    • KR 1.2 15% of logged-out users users who open the Activity tab click on the prompt for unlocking insights
  • Guardrails
    • Revert rate in the variant groups B or C does not exceed 18%
  • Curiosities
    • What other features are users looking for in the activity tab? What did they expect to see there? (Survey)
    • By how much did the constructive activation rate vary across groups A, B, and C?
    • How many accounts were created from the activity tab?
Test plan

Wrap up in 30-day A/B/C test
Everyone on zh, fr, tr, es is in the test. All other wikis see current History tab.

    • A Group - 1/3 see no activity tab, keep current history tab
    • B Group - 1/3 see new A activity tab with generic edit CTA.
    • C Group - 1/3 see new A activity tab with Add an Image edit CTA.
  • Show to iPhone users only
Must Haves
  • Reading history should still be accessible for users who opt not to log-in or engage with the Activity tab (Ensure VoiceOver users especially can still access History)
  • All users in target audiences see the new Activity tab
  • Logged-out users
    • See prompt to log-in/create an account for insights
  • Logged-in users
    • Control: Prompt them to edit to make their editing stats increase
    • Variant: Prompt them to add an image to make their editing stats increase. Show entry point to Add an image
    • Both: Display at least one reading insight
  • “Add an image” is available to users under 50 edits for the target audiences in the experiment group
  • Editing stats increase after someone makes an edit
  • After engaging with the Activity tab, users are asked for their feedback through an in-app survey or Google Form survey
Target Quant Regions and Languages

15-day experiment with all app users in the following languages would see the experimental Activity Tab

  • Chinese
  • French
  • Turkish
  • Spanish
Target Qualitative Audience
  • Newcomers
  • Engaged readers
Concepts

https://whimsical.com/ios-activity-tab-TaLYNNWgMfhn6VM1Lb1Xja

Screenshot 2025-04-09 at 4.36.28 PM.png (2×1 px, 813 KB)
image.png (2×1 px, 421 KB)
image.png (1×786 px, 94 KB)

Final designs: https://www.figma.com/design/G80XioWE4CdjKdcOQ14dJv/iOS---Activity-tab?node-id=113-3701&m=dev

QA Notes

This experiment will be ready starting in TestFlight 7.7.5 (5209).

  • Note that upon first launch of the new app version, the app will randomly assign a user to the experiment if you have a target wiki as a primary app language (33% in group A control, 33% in group B generic edit CTA, 33% in group C Add an image CTA).
  • If you need to force a particular variant for testing, you can subsequently go into Developer settings and choose a particular toggle. Note that after selecting a toggle, you must terminate the app and relaunch for the override to take effect.

Related Objects

Event Timeline

There are a very large number of changes, so older changes are hidden. Show Older Changes
Tsevener updated the task description. (Show Details)
Tsevener updated the task description. (Show Details)
HNordeenWMF renamed this task from [Epic] Activity Tab Experiment to [Epic] [WE 1.2] Activity Tab Experiment .Apr 17 2025, 5:10 PM

It's looking generally really good!

A few issues I'm seeing:

[must fix] Stats not showing in every language (device language)

  • ✅ Spanish - Counts are showing as expected
  • French - I'm not seeing the count part of the # of edits that I have (1) after editing. The first line should read Vous avez edite 1 fois...
    IMG_7B49C4F0B653-1.jpeg (2×1 px, 619 KB)
  • Turkish - I'm not seeing the count part of the # of edits, # of saved articles, or # articles read
    IMG_616EAABF0690-1.jpeg (2×1 px, 554 KB)
  • ✅ Chinese - Counts are showing as expected

[nice-to-have] For the B Group's link to Editing section of the FAQ Page https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Wikimedia_Apps/iOS_FAQ#Editing

  • Amal is working on getting this page translated. It would be great if the link could lead to the language version of the link, according to either device language or primary language. Spanish has this part of the page translated, and when I have Spanish as a device language and primary language, it still leads to the English mediawiki page

@ABorbaWMF could you please confirm that "View reading history" for logged-out users still works with VoiceOver?

@ABorbaWMF Fixes will be in TestFlight build 7.7.5 (5231). Can you retest? Thanks!