Page MenuHomePhabricator

Edit Check + Suggestions: Evaluate removing icons by default in Buttons
Closed, DeclinedPublic

Description

Background

At the moment, the Edit Check cards include 3 icons: the one indicating the feedback status of the check (e.g. warning) and the icon in each of its 2 actions. The main icon in the Edit Check card should be the start icon in the card that indicates the type of check (check/suggestion). Using more icons in the buttons adds noise and makes the card heavier and less scanable.

This task is to evaluate removing the icons from the Checks + Suggestions cards:

image.png (640×368 px, 81 KB)
image.png (640×368 px, 80 KB)
Current behavior: using icons in buttons.Proposed solution: remove the icons by default in buttons and use them just in case we ned to make one of the buttons more prominent for some specific reason.

Design proposal

Once the design proposal has been created in Figma, remove this note and link the Figma file below.

Design proposal

Acceptance criteria (or Done)

Design

  • Evaluate removing the icons from check's buttons by default
  • (If needed) Test both options with users and decide on best solution

Implementation

  • Implement decided changes

Event Timeline

I recommend running a quick usability test to inform this decision with real data.

bmartinezcalvo renamed this task from Edit Check: Evaluate removing icons by default in Buttons to Edit Check + Suggestions: Evaluate removing icons by default in Buttons.Mar 17 2026, 3:05 PM

Icon in buttons don't appear now on any checks or suggestions, so declining this task since it looks like it was solved.