Page MenuHomePhabricator

Investigate Contributor metrics growth in Wikidata (and Commons)
Open, MediumPublic

Description

Nov 2025

We are seeing growth across multiple contributor metrics on Wikidata+Commons. See Nov-2025 metrics report. We should investigate what might be causing these increases.

  • which wiki is driving the change - wikidata or commons ?
  • across dimensions - platform, pages, etc.
July 2025 description

We're seeing slight YoY growth in new active editors in May, June, July 2025, after a long spell of declines that started in 2021. Between 2019 and 2024, new active editors have decreased by 20% (see report)

We should keep an eye on this trend to see if it continues and investigate where the growth is and what caused it. Some areas to explore

  • which wikis see YoY growth?
    • in May and June emerging wikis contributed to the growth. Declines were seen in developed wikis
    • the timing coincides with the rollout of temp accounts T340001 to major wikis. it would be good to check if we are effectively removing temp accounts and data QA of upstream tables (mediawiki_history)
  • Which countries saw increases?
    • we can only get top new editor countries for the latest month since editors_daily only stores 30-60 days of data. comparison may not be possible
  • Platform - desktop or mobile growth?

Event Timeline

Mayakp.wiki updated the task description. (Show Details)

I'm confident it's not temp wikis. In editor_month, all of the temp users have the user_is_temporary flag, and our active editor query simply users WHERE NOT user_is_temporary in both of the appropriate places.

I also broke down new active editors by "main wiki" (the wiki where the new editor made the most edits). By far the biggest April–July changes (note: not the same as the year-over-year change) were at Wikidata and Commons, which haven't had temp accounts deployed yet.

Source code for this analysis.

thanks @nshahquinn-wmf , I checked YoY numbers using your code and the growth seems to be from Commons and wikidata as well.
In conjunction to the growth in Commons, I saw that net new content on Commons has increased, we usually attribute this to bot contributions but surprisingly this month we had a lot of new content added by non-bot users on Commons and Wikidata!

We continue to see these trends in August as well.
Wikidata seems to be pulling most of the weight in the new active editor growth in July and Aug 2025. here's why -
in July 2025, Wikidata accounted for more than half the growth in new active ed increases; and in Aug 2025 Wikidata increases were more than the overall new active editor increases.

raw numbers -
July 2025, had an increase of 2113 new active editors compared to july 2024, and wikidata saw an inc of 1204, while commons had an increase of 921 new active editors.
Aug 2025, had an inc of 849 new active editors compared to last yr; wikidata saw 116% inc ie 938 new active editors growth, while commons had an increase of 334 new active editors.

Mayakp.wiki renamed this task from Investigate New Active Editors growth to Investigate Contributor metrics growth in Wikidata (and Commons).Dec 18 2025, 11:22 PM
Mayakp.wiki updated the task description. (Show Details)