Page MenuHomePhabricator

[SPIKE] Decide what – if any – features will we remove from Suggestion Mode MVP
Closed, DuplicatePublic

Description

In T404470, we will be offering the initial / "base" version of Suggestion Mode via a URL parameter.

This task involves the work of decide what – if any – features/aspects of the MVP (T399612) we will remove prior to this initial release.

Decision(s) to be made

  • What – if any – features/aspects of the MVP (T399612) we will remove prior to this initial release?
  • What aspects of the MVP (T399612) UX do we need to consider prioritizing before T399611 and ultimately, T404600?

Done

  • 1. Review both variants of the Suggestion Mode MVP (T399612):
  • 2. Document aspects of the MVP (T399612) UX do we need to consider prioritizing before T399611 and ultimately, T404600
  • 3. Prioritize issues identified through "2."

Background

During a 10 Sep 2025 offline discussion, the Editing Team converged on an approach for developing Suggestion Mode wherein we will:

  1. Release a "pared down" version of the existing MVP (T399612) and
  2. As needed, iterate upon this base version with enhancements/features as needed

i. Where "all experimental checks" refers to the following, per T404599#11182097:

  • ConvertReference
  • Disambiguation
  • ExternalLink
  • ToneCheck
  • Paste (but wouldn't give you anything on existing content)
  • TextMatch (code only stops you from writing 'unfortunately' for testing, could be extended with community config, see: T398478)

Event Timeline

(The MVP has already had feedback surveys stripped out of suggestions, incidentally.)

With just suggestions you'll only see AddReference.

The current set of checks that experimental turns on is:

  • ConvertReference
  • Disambiguation
  • ExternalLink
  • ToneCheck
  • Paste (but wouldn't give you anything on existing content)
  • TextMatch (code only stops you from writing 'unfortunately' for testing, could be extended with community config, see: T398478)

Over time, this ticket and T402242 ended up coming to refer to the same work.