Page MenuHomePhabricator

Design Research: Account Registration audit and best-practice review
Closed, ResolvedPublic5 Estimated Story Points

Description

Description:

This task focuses on early research to inform a comprehensive review and redesign of the account creation experience on Wikimedia wikis.

Details:

Account creation is the first interaction many potential contributors have with Wikipedia, and the current flow is outdated, cluttered, and can create confusion.

For logged-out users, dense text, multiple warnings, pop-ups, and a complex interface can discourage registration. For logged-in users, Special:CreateAccount serves dual purposes—creating accounts for oneself versus creating accounts for others—which can lead to confusion, unintentional duplicates, and a user experience that diverges from common web conventions.

The goal of this project is to modernize the interface, clarify workflows, reduce friction, and ensure that account creation behaves as expected for all user types while maintaining necessary functionality for trusted users.

Strategic Alignment:

This project supports the Contributor Strategy by improving the earliest interactions in the contribution funnel. A clearer, modernized account creation experience strengthens clarity, engagement, and motivation for new contributors.

User Stories:

As a newcomer,

  • I want a clear, simple, and welcoming account creation process so that I can register easily and start editing without confusion.
  • I want to understand the benefits of creating an account (e.g., tracking edits, receiving notifications, connecting with mentors) so that I feel motivated to complete registration.
  • I want appropriately timed prompts to appear when I try to edit while logged out so that I can create an account without interrupting my workflow.
  • I want a streamlined interface with minimal warnings and pop-ups so that I don’t feel overwhelmed or discouraged from completing registration.

As an experienced editor,

  • I want to be able to create accounts for other users (e.g., for editathons or rate limited IPs) so that I can support contributors efficiently.
  • I want the system to make clear when I am creating a new account for someone else versus modifying my own account so that I avoid accidental duplicate accounts.
  • I want the ability to override filters or restrictions when appropriate so that I can create accounts intentionally while

As a temporary account holder,

  • I want guidance and encouragement to convert my temporary account into a full account so that I can access a personal Homepage and continue contributing without losing my progress
Opportunities that may be considered:
  • Modernize and clarify the account creation experience
  • Simplify the interface for logged-out and logged-in users
  • Make the design mobile-friendly and visually clear
  • Reduce cognitive overload by removing unnecessary text, warnings, and pop-ups
  • Explain benefits of account creation, such as edit tracking, notifications, and mentorship
  • Audit logged-in user flows on Special:CreateAccount
  • Identify pain points and confusion for users creating accounts for themselves or others
  • Explore design solutions that prevent accidental duplicate account creation while preserving functionality for trusted users (e.g., event organizers)
  • Align the experience with standard web UX patterns
  • Experiment with engagement strategies for new users
  • Streamline the “create an account” entry point from the logged-out editing view
  • [In consideration]Test in-context prompts when users attempt to edit while logged out
  • [In consideration] Surface account creation on mobile.
  • [In consideration] Encourage Temporary Accounts to convert to regular accounts
  • [In consideration] Investigate ways to reduce the negative impact of IP blocks on good-faith newcomers
  • [In consideration] Experiment further with surfacing editing opportunities to engaged readers.
Acceptance Criteria:
  • Review of existing Account Creation Funnel data, and suggestions for further data analysis to help guide our approach.
  • Completion of research and competitor analysis with clear documentation of findings.
  • Identification of high-priority pain points or friction areas in the current flows.
  • Early design recommendations to guide future design work.

Event Timeline

KStoller-WMF renamed this task from Design Research: Audit and improve the account creation experience across Wikimedia wikis to Design Research: Account Registration audit and best-practice review.Nov 19 2025, 8:21 PM
KStoller-WMF moved this task from Inbox to Product Backlog on the Growth-Team board.
KStoller-WMF moved this task from Product Backlog to Needs Estimation on the Growth-Team board.
KStoller-WMF lowered the priority of this task from High to Medium.Nov 25 2025, 11:47 PM
KStoller-WMF set the point value for this task to 5.
KStoller-WMF removed a subscriber: SydneyRug.

we've looked at the top 20 services across web[1], ios[2], and android[3] to build off jakob's law[4], and we've started to compile a comp review[5]. the figma file takes a while to load, be patient :)

most of those services are US-/english-based, so next steps is to explore local examples across languages and countries too. we'd like also to include services that "heavily" rely on usernames as identities.


[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most-visited_websites
[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/App_Store_(Apple)#Most_downloaded_apps
[3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most_popular_Android_apps
[4]: https://lawsofux.com/jakobs-law/
[5]: https://www.figma.com/design/ZGAyOO0oVdGX0MV2yOXEf8/T408649-account-creation?node-id=4-354&t=0oqqecIpEFuwjNZm-1

we've finalized the comp review, and put the findings together in a slide deck (internal google slides).