Page MenuHomePhabricator

[EPIC] Expand recognition of the individual
Open, Needs TriagePublic

Description

User stories:

As an editor, I want to be able to thank an editor for their contributions overall, so that I can have an easy, light-weight to recognize them for their contributions overall.

Concept:

Right now, the main way to recognize an individual overall (rather than for a specific edit) is through wikilove. However, wikilove may not be ideal for every scenario. It feels a bit higher stakes, since it generates a templated reward of sorts that goes on the user talk page, which often has a quirky vibe, an image, and sometimes even lengthy text. Meanwhile, thanks is meant to be quick and easy, and it doesn't need to necessarily exist as a permanent record on the user talk page. So, we're wondering if we could allow a way to thank an editor overall, and maybe an explanation can be given (see T407292), but it is quick, structured data on the rationale for the thanks rather than the more unstructured, loose form of recognition found in wikilove.

Things to consider:
  • How would users discover that they can thank an individual overall? Where would this live? On the user page? Via a thanks dialog that may also be used to say why you're thanking the editor (i.e., thank for an individual edit for for larger work in general)?
  • How would thanks for an individual interact with/complement wikilove? When would someone choose to use one over the other? If someone is on a user page, would they still see the heart for wikilove, or would it also be for thanks?
  • Make recognition heart be for wikilove or thanks to individual
  • Thanks to individual should be in thanks log
  • Should work on desktop & mobile

Design concepts:

design explorations for thanking the individual’s overall contributions (instead of a single edit)

designnotes
heart icon_user page.png (1,280×2,272 px, 73 KB)
perhaps we can add a heart icon in user pages as an entry point to thank/send wikilove to an individual.
iPhone SE - 4 (1).png (1,280×2,272 px, 177 KB)
when the user clicks on the heart icon, a menu comes up where they can choose whether to thank or send WikiLove to that user. each option has a description that explains the difference between the two
sending thanks.png (1,280×2,272 px, 256 KB)
same flow as T407292: Create design concepts to allow editors to have the option to say why giving thanks, but this time we are clarifying in the subtitle that you’re sending thanks for overall contributions, and not just one edit

sending wikilove
this whole WikiLove concept for mobile is new since we couldn’t find a way to send wikilove through a mobile device.

designnotes
wikilove step 1.png (1,280×2,272 px, 218 KB)
step 1 — selecting the type of wikilove
wikilove step 2.png (1,280×2,272 px, 228 KB)
step 2 — selecting food or drink item
wikilove step 3.png (1,280×2,272 px, 186 KB)
step 3 — entering a header + message
wikilove step 4.png (1,280×2,272 px, 397 KB)
preview
iPhone SE - 9 (1).png (1,280×2,272 px, 310 KB)
confirmation message

public log
for thanks action, log on the list could say “UserX thanked UserY for their overall contributions”

iPhone SE - 10 (1).png (1,280×2,912 px, 157 KB)

notification
notification would clarify that you were thanked for your overall contributions — same with e-mail

Frame 13 (4).png (320×586 px, 8 KB)