Page MenuHomePhabricator

Email forwarding from arbcom-en(at)wikipedia.org to arbcom-en(at)wikimedia.org
Closed, DeclinedPublic

Description

The English Wikipedia Arbitration Committee's email address is arbcom-en(at)wikimedia.org.

We know for a fact that editors send emails to the incorrect arbcom-en(at)wikipedia.org, and multiple arbitrators have made the same mistake (example 1, example 2, example 3). It is incredibly important that emails sent to the wrong address are not missed; we receive many time-sensitive emails regarding user safety.

The Committee is formally requesting that the WMF forward email from arbcom-en(at)wikipedia.org to arbcom-en(at)wikimedia.org. Thanks in advance!

Event Timeline

jhathaway subscribed.

@Elli though this is technically possible, outside of some existing corner cases, I am not sure the added confusion of having multiple domains is worth the occasional bounced email.

Hello @jhathaway , I work in Trust & Safety on the Community Governance Support team as the Foundation's Lead Community Governance Specialist. Thank you for looking into this task previously. The English Wikipedia ArbCom recently made us aware of this request, and we believe that they have a credible concern that emails to Arbcom about community conduct issues may be getting lost due to confusion between the Wikipedia/Wikimedia naming in the email. The request is for an email alias from arbcom-en@wikipedia.org to arbcom-en@wikimedia.org in order to clear up confusion, not to create more confusion, as this is a regular problem for normal users of our websites who regularly attempt to send @wikipeia.org emails. It is extremely important that user conduct issues have all credible paths possible to contact the Arbitration Committee.

With this context, I hope that SRE can re-evaluate this request.

To chime in as a member of the English Wikipedia Arbitration Committee, I know at least one important email was missed in the last year because it was sent to the incorrect @wikipedia.org address. We only know about that instance because the sender was fortunate enough to cc VRT info-en. This issue is not new. Over the years, many sitting arbitrators have instructed editors to email the @wikipedia.org address (example 1; example 2, example 3). If the people who are subscribed to arbcom-en make that mistake, I am certain that less experienced editors regularly do, too.

HouseBlaster renamed this task from Suggestion: email forwarding from wikipedia.org to wikimedia.org to Email forwarding from arbcom-en(at)wikipedia.org to arbcom-en(at)wikimedia.org.Thu, Oct 22, 8:12 PM
HouseBlaster updated the task description. (Show Details)