Page MenuHomePhabricator

Suggestions: Improve the navigation of suggestions across the article
Open, HighPublic

Description

Background

As a result of T415933, we detected that we could improve the navigation of suggestions across the article to avoid long scroll, especially in long articles with many sections.

This task is to explore possible solutions for the navigation of suggestions across long articles (desktop + mobile, but especially on mobile).

User stories

As someone who is view a suggestion within an article (either by way of tapping View suggestions (T414518), tapping on the suggestion "rail," or text a suggestion is relevant to), I want a quick way to navigate to the other suggestions that are available within in the article, so that I can efficiently review them without needing to manually scroll through the page to find each one.

Open questions

  • 1. How (if at all) might the UX this task describes relate to the broader plans we have for the following...?
    • Introducing a "place" where people can see all of the Suggestions they've acted on within an edit session
    • Introducing a "place" where people can see all of the Suggestions they've declined/skipped/dismissed within an edit session
    • Introducing a way for people to filter suggestions by type/priority/difficulty/etc.
  • 2. How (if at all) would this UX affect how Edit Checks are presented during the mid-edit moment?

Artifacts

Design mockups, prototypes, etc.

Design proposal

Acceptance criteria (or Done)

Design

Implementation

  • List here any acceptance criteria related to implementation

Event Timeline

After exploring different approaches for suggestion navigation, we’ve aligned on the following direction:

We will use the existing pagination pattern (currently used in the pre-save moment and in the multiple checks) to navigate between suggestions. This will allow us to reuse familiar UI elements and avoid introducing new patterns into the system. We will use the decided solution to navigate both Suggestions and Checks across the article.

Captura de pantalla 2026-04-28 a las 19.59.59.png (668×377 px, 96 KB)
Captura de pantalla 2026-04-28 a las 20.01.34.png (612×1 px, 296 KB)
mobiledesktop

For what happens after a suggestion is completed or dismissed, there are 2 possible options that will be validated through usability testing in T424677:

Grabación de pantalla 2026-04-28 a las 19.55.23.gif (334×187 px, 872 KB)
Op.1: No auto-advance after dismissing a suggestion (user manually navigates)
Grabación de pantalla 2026-04-28 a las 19.56.17.gif (334×187 px, 1 MB)
Op.2: Auto-advance to the next suggestion after dismissing

Moving this task to Blocked until the usability testing in T424677 is completed and we can make an informed decision.