Appear as logged out on some pages and logged in on others
Closed, DeclinedPublic

Description

Author: skatepunk319

Description:
After logging in I will browse http://en.wikipedia.org/ and will appear as
logged in on some pages and logged out on others. The problem started when I had
to switch from cable internet to satellite internet (specifically DirecWay).

  • I Do Use

Microsoft Windows XP: Home Edition (Version 2002, Service Pack 2)
Mozilla FireFox 1.0.4.
Internet Explorer 6.0.
Windows Firewall

  • I Don't Use

Ad-blocking software

  • Failed to Solve the Problem

Turning off firewall
Clearing cache
Removing all cookies
Specifying en.wikipedia.org cookies to always be allowed
Unchecking the "Remember Me" checkbox during login
Checking the "Remember Me" checkbox during login

I have read on the Wiki help page that I may have a proxy problem. That seems
very likely because satellite connections use proxy servers and I did not have
this problem before I switched to a satellite connection--ruling out
cookie/cache problems.

I have tested on another computer in the house and received the exact same
results as I do on this computer.

Searching for this bug in Wikipedia's bugzilla yielded no relevant results.


Version: 1.4.x
Severity: minor
OS: Mac OS X 10.4
Platform: Macintosh

Details

Reference
bz2237
bzimport set Reference to bz2237.
bzimport added a subscriber: Unknown Object (MLST).

skatepunk319 wrote:

I don't seem to have the problem on http://bugzilla.wikipedia.org/

I changed the product from MediaWiki to Wikimedia web sites.

guido.schlabitz wrote:

Yes, Yes! Same problem here. Also using DirecWay. Let me know if I can be of
help in testing this annoying little bugger.

zigger wrote:

If the ISP proxy is causing inconsistent session/cache/header problems, it will
probably occur on any MediaWiki site. Bugzilla is not a wiki -- it has just
been styled to look like the MediaWiki Monobook skin. Changing product back
from "Wikimedia web sites".

The ISP may be able to explain their proxy anomaly, assuming that they know
about it. Otherwise, can someone attach HTTP traces for good and bad page
requests? (see http://livehttpheaders.mozdev.org/ )

skatepunk319 wrote:

HTTP traces for good and bad page requests

I hope the attachment is what you were requesting. The last request was the
only bad one (showed me as logged out), the rest were good ones (showed me as
logged in). Ugh! I hope I'm helping.

Attached: thisisonlyforyou.txt

skatepunk319 wrote:

I have session/cache/header problems only on MediaWiki sites. I think there is a
bug in the MediaWiki code, and not my ISP, that's causing the problem. Don't
forget to check out the HTTP traces I attached to my previous comment, I hope
that's what you were asking for.

hahn wrote:

related to bug 1396 possibly since all of a sudden, i am experiencing both.

robchur wrote:

Is the ISP using a caching proxy?

skatepunk319 wrote:

Yes, they use it to accelerate browsing since we're on a satellite connection.

heathhunnicutt wrote:

Internet Explorer will attempt a special refresh if you press Shift+F5, but
I don't think it works around this sort of proxy-cache problem. For that,
you have to bypass the proxy, somehow.

pawblo.art wrote:

I am having the same problem and am using Hughesnet satellite (formerly
Direcway)but with a Mac. I will log in and will appear to be logged in but as
soon as I click on any link, I am logged out again. This happens across all
browsers. Latest versions of Firefox, Safari, Camino, and Explorer. I have
cleared the cache, cookies, history, stored passwords, and have no firewall.

brion added a comment.Oct 16 2006, 8:20 PM

Kevin: that's just because your satellite connection has broken
proxies which break many web sites, including Wikipedia.
Disable the proxies or use the experimental HTTPS interface.
Contact your provider for information about proxies.

pawblo.art wrote:

thankyou, it was in the explorer preferences interface where i had to disable
the proxies and it sets this parameter for all applications. Direcway has a
help section that led me to the preferences.

very cool...

demon added a comment.Jan 2 2009, 8:43 PM

WORKSFORME (both software and WMF). Isn't an issue with the software, but rather the ISP of the users, as Brion mentions in comment 11

Add Comment