Page MenuHomePhabricator

Prevent Suggestion Mode overlap during guided article creation
Open, Needs TriagePublic

Description

When a user creates a new article using the Article Guidance workflow, Suggestion Mode should not be active. Suggestion mode is supposed to appear when content already exists, not when creating a new article.

Potential causes to investigate

  • Pre-loaded content triggering Suggestion Mode: Article Guidance pre-loads structural content into the Visual Editor for the user to replace. This pre-loaded content may be triggering Suggestion Mode checks, which is misleading since the structural content is guidance to be replaced by actual written content by the user. Suggestion Mode should not start on pre-loaded Article Guidance content.

Expected behaviour

Suggestion Mode should not be active when a user is creating a new article through the Article Guidance workflow. Any checks on user-provided content happening in a new article via Article Guidance should be handled by the regular EditChecks, not Suggestion Mode.

Next steps

  • Confirm whether this is addressable through experiment configuration settings for the Suggestion Mode experiment. Related tasks:
  • T418297 - Introduce ways to disable suggestions
  • T396029 - Article Guidance epic
  • If not, identify what code changes are needed to prevent Suggestion Mode from firing on pre-loaded Article Guidance content
  • Coordinate with the Editing team on the right approach

People to involve

Related tasks

  • T418297 - Introduce ways to disable suggestions
  • T396029 - Article Guidance epic