@ABorbaWMF linking this comment here with more info https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T427623#12092109

@ABorbaWMF @Mazevedo Can you please review the iPad section of AC2 and all of AC4? Thanks!

Test Result - Test Flight

Status: ✅ PASS / ❌ FAIL
Environment: Test Flight- Wikipedia 8.2.2 (6106)
OS: macOS Tahoe 26.5.1
Browser: Chrome 149
Device: MBA
Emulated Device: BrowserStack- iPhone 17 v26.5; iPad Air 13 v18.6

Test Artifact(s):

• iOS Wikipedia App
• Italian Wikipedia
• Catalan Wikipedia
• Hebrew Wikipedia

Test Steps

Test Case 1: Ensure article images load correctly on Italian Wikipedia

1. Open the iOS Wikipedia app.
2. Switch to the Italian Wikipedia.
3. Open an article containing one or more images.
4. Wait for the article to finish loading.
5. Observe the images within the article.
6. ✅ AC1: All article images load successfully without missing, broken, or incorrect images.

Test Case 2: Ensure article images load correctly on Catalan Wikipedia

1. Switch to the Catalan Wikipedia.
2. Open an article containing one or more images.
3. Wait for the article to finish loading.
4. Observe the images within the article.
5. ✅ AC2: All article images load successfully without missing, broken, or incorrect images.

❌Video same as Itallian just in Catalan but I did come across an image that didn't open but the others were fine in Top Read

Test Case 3: Ensure article images load correctly on Hebrew Wikipedia

1. Switch to the Hebrew Wikipedia.
2. Open an article containing one or more images.
3. Wait for the article to finish loading.
4. Observe the images within the article.
5. ✅ AC3: All article images load successfully without missing, broken, or incorrect images.

Video same as Itallian but just in Hebrew. Nothing worth recording since it's the same as Itallian.

Ipad

Test Case 4: Ensure images can be shared from an article

1. Open an article containing an image on one of the supported Wikipedias.
2. Select an article image.
3. Select the Share option.
4. Observe the share sheet.
5. ❌ AC4: The image can be shared successfully using the iOS share sheet.

There is no sharing option. Is this a BrowserStack issue?

@ABorbaWMF For prioritization, it would be help to know: Are the things that are broken unique to the languages
Italian Wikipedia
Catalan Wikipedia
Hebrew Wikipedia ?

Or happening also on other languages (i.e. existing bugs in the App)

Hi there! Following up, are there any updates on this? Thanks.

Is it intentional that clicking on the hero image often opens a completely different image? It looks a bit weird.

❌ AC4: The image can be shared successfully using the iOS share sheet.
There is no sharing option. Is this a BrowserStack issue?

@GMikesell-WMF there should be a share option displaying when you tap open an image from Article view. I'm seeing it in your video, so looks OK.

❌Video same as Itallian just in Catalan but I did come across an image that didn't open but the others were fine in Top Read

@GMikesell-WMF was this just a single occurence, and only happened on Italian & Catalan? Could you try if sometime similar happens on English (that would help us know if it's a new bug vs existing)?

In T431425#12158621, @OWresch-WMF wrote:

Hi there! Following up, are there any updates on this? Thanks.

Hoping to signoff today/tomorrow!

In T431425#12158656, @Tgr wrote:

Is it intentional that clicking on the hero image often opens a completely different image? It looks a bit weird.

It's a known bug that happens only on certain articles (https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T429461) - are you seeing it everywhere or only some places?

In T431425#12164161, @HNordeenWMF wrote:

❌ AC4: The image can be shared successfully using the iOS share sheet.
There is no sharing option. Is this a BrowserStack issue?

@GMikesell-WMF there should be a share option displaying when you tap open an image from Article view. I'm seeing it in your video, so looks OK.

@HNordeenWMF
It has the icon but it doesn't have the options to share like Airdrop, message or email as seen in the video below. I'm not sure if this is just a BrowserStack issue or if it's also on the physical device too. I don't have a physical device to check unfortunately.

In T431425#12164208, @HNordeenWMF wrote:

It's a known bug that happens only on certain articles (https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T429461) - are you seeing it everywhere or only some places?

I don't have an iOS phone, I was just looking at the videos.

In T431425#12164199, @HNordeenWMF wrote:

❌Video same as Itallian just in Catalan but I did come across an image that didn't open but the others were fine in Top Read

@GMikesell-WMF was this just a single occurence, and only happened on Italian & Catalan? Could you try if sometime similar happens on English (that would help us know if it's a new bug vs existing)?

@HNordeenWMF To me it seems like it's more a one off on some images. As you seen in the Catalan language, I did come across it again and the last image had issues. That specific image seems to have trouble in both iPad and iPhone as seen in the videos below. English was fine though.

It has the icon but it doesn't have the options to share like Airdrop, message or email as seen in the video below. I'm not sure if this is just a BrowserStack issue or if it's also on the physical device too. I don't have a physical device to check unfortunately.

Oh, yes that does look like a browserstack limitation.

To me it seems like it's more a one off on some images. As you seen in the Catalan language, I did come across it again and the last image had issues. That specific image seems to have trouble in both iPad and iPhone as seen in the videos below. English was fine though.

Because the Susanna Griso i Raventos image does work on other languages other than Catalan (especially English which uses the exact same image file), it seems it might be related to the change that happened.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1pF0ssy2jpWuohUDAw_2HgthBDD5tF2aC/view?usp=sharing
When I go to share that image, I see an error: {F96315598}.
@Mazevedo or @Tgr , could this be related to the media provenance then? I am worried since I don't know how many images this could potentially affect

In T431425#12165128, @HNordeenWMF wrote:

It has the icon but it doesn't have the options to share like Airdrop, message or email as seen in the video below. I'm not sure if this is just a BrowserStack issue or if it's also on the physical device too. I don't have a physical device to check unfortunately.

Oh, yes that does look like a browserstack limitation.

Got it, ok sounds good. I will mark that pass then.

In T431425#12165130, @HNordeenWMF wrote:

To me it seems like it's more a one off on some images. As you seen in the Catalan language, I did come across it again and the last image had issues. That specific image seems to have trouble in both iPad and iPhone as seen in the videos below. English was fine though.

Because the Susanna Griso i Raventos image does work on other languages other than Catalan (especially English which uses the exact same image file), it seems it might be related to the change that happened.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1pF0ssy2jpWuohUDAw_2HgthBDD5tF2aC/view?usp=sharing
When I go to share that image, I see an error: {F96315598}.
@Mazevedo or @Tgr , could this be related to the media provenance then? I am worried since I don't know how many images this could potentially affect

Yeah I'm sure there are other images too since Pedro Porro in my first example with Catalan ,was happening the same way too

I suspect the image is being broken due to the wikidata infobox implementation specifically on Catlan wiki which is appending ?lang=ca to the image <a> tag and seemingly then being treated by other parts of the pipeline as the actual file name.

Which is why the image is broken on cawiki but not italian Wikipedia for the article Pedro Porro which isn't using a wikidata infobox but does use the same image. Or why there are no issues on articles like Cava which doesn't use a wikidata infobox. Looking at other wikidata infobox articles on cawiki seem to share the issue.

I'm surprised that the Module would want manipulate the URL in that manner out of choice. I tested a few other biography wikidata infoboxes and couldn't find another example. What then is happneing is that Mediawiki is interpreting the image URL string as a legitimate part of the image file name and which then is getting getting used elsewhere.

I'm surprised this hasn't gotten caught before so I wonder if there is anything maybe has gotten tweaked here that's allowing the url string to remain appended in the <a> tag to be exposed in this way? I'd really like to confirm that this is an issue constrained to cawiki and not other wiki's using wikidata infoboxes.

We don't think the image not loading issue on Catalan we're seeing is related to this change, but rather an existing bug that we'll file and address.

@Tgr and @Krinkle : @Seddon and I are OK with this change scaling now.